Posted December 01, 2012
StingingVelvet: As much as I love Fallout and some others I do prefer action combat or real time with pause in RPGs. Turn-based strategy is awesome as a genre but in RPGs it tends to feel slow and kills the immersion factor.
I haven't found too many games that managed it as well as Arcanum (which is extremely similar to Fallout/2). I do think the VATS system in the new Fallouts is a decent compromise. And as much as I love the old Wasteland/Bard's Tale style of combat, I can't see that catching on outside a nostalgic demographic. As for JRPGs, while I've found many fun, the combat is inevitably too easy every single time. Yes, there are exceptions (hello Etrian Odyssey, fuck you today), so I guess I'm exaggerating, but the exceptions are so niche I feel like the major portion of the gaming demographic literally never runs into them.
Coelocanth: I like some turn-based games and think there are some that couldn't really work well any other way. But do I want all my RPGs to be turn-bsaed? Gods, no. As long as there are same that are TB, some that are RT, and some that are RTwP, I'm quite happy with it.
And as usual, someone has stated my mind better than I have. This! Sir, pour yourself a scotch!
Post edited December 01, 2012 by orcishgamer