That bothered me too at first but the game isn't that hard and the humour was enough to drive me through it.

I kinda lost interest already in the beginning parts, when trying to save the dropping brainies. I just didn't like that part at all. But I must retry, just for the humor in the game.

That's one of the worst, most off-putting and most atypical levels of the game, I think, and curiously it's the second level already. So many people seem to get stuck there (including myself and a friend of mine). :D

If you manage to complete it, things will get a lot better afterwards.

Psychonauts, but only because my PC can't handle it without intense and frequent lag spikes, so I'll be putting it off for a while.

You must retry, because he has saggy balls!

Haven't played these mainly because I haven't gotten around to them I guess. Some of them I did spend 2-3 hours on and then got distracted. A whole lot of these I also have to wait to play till I get around to fixing my desktop (which has been broken for over 2 years now).

Knights of the Old Republic
Gothic 2
Thief 1-3
The Witcher
Arcanum
Fallout 3
Batman Arkham City
Metro 2033
Mass Effect
Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines
King's Quest / Space Quest / Quest for Glory collections
Ultima Underworld 2
Oblivion
Sacrifice
Geneforge 3-5
Outcast
Might & Magic 7
Zork: Grand Inquisitor
Descent 2
Giants: Citizen Kabuto
Earthworm Jim 1&2
Fallout Tactics
Space Rangers 2: Reboot
Space Pirates and Zombies
Gabriel Knight 3
Journeyman Project 2-3
Penumbra trilogy
Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Avernum remake and 4-5
Borderlands
Commandos series
Oddworld 1&2
Darksiders
Deus Ex: Human Revolution
Dreamfall: The Longest Journey
Dragon Age: Origins Ultimate Edition
Dustforce
F.E.A.R.
Freedom Force vs. the 3rd Reich
Frozen Synapse
GTA 1-4
Gratuitous Space Battles
Hard Reset
Hitman 1-3
Jade Empire
Just Cause 2
King's Bounty: AP & Crossworlds
Legend of Grimrock
Magicka
Max Payne 2
Neverwinter Nights 2: Platinum
Rochard
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - all 3
Sam & Max season 3
Tales of Monkey Island
Vast majority of Sega Classics collection
Shank
Sid Meier's Pirates! (the remake)
Splinter Cell series
To the Moon
Trine 2
X-COM: Terror from the Deep
X series
Zeno Clash
Escape Goat
Bioforge
Icewind Dale 2
Ultima 5-7

Games I have, but haven't even touched:
Fallout 3
Unreal
Unreal Tournament 2004
Super Meat Boy
Civ V
The Longest Journey
Far Cry
Broken Sword
Alan Wake
Bioshock 2
Outcast
Gabriel Knight
Trine
Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines

Then there's a bunch more that's I've started but haven't finished:
Deus Ex
Metro 2033
Serious Sam HD
Frozen Synapse
Doom 3
Thief
Alpha Centauri

Probably... erm... No One Lives Forever 2, I guess? Couldn't get it to work on my old computer, and have been busy with other games on my current one. Plus, since it's an original CD, I expect getting it to play nicely with Windows 7 will be a little bit of a hassle.

Spend 2-3 hours on Escape Goat, maybe that would be even enough to complete it and you could already uncheck one game of that long list. And you probably won't regret it either, unless these kinds of games and graphics don't appeal to you at all. I thought it was great.

Well after the Interplay sale recently (not to mention the THQ humble bundle, good lord)... a lot of "good games".

Games I get on sale I have a bad habit of never getting around to playing, usually getting caught up in a million and a half other things. Playing Company of Heroes right now, I'm missing out on Baldur's Gate II, Planetscape, Bioshock (yep, owned it for over half a year now and haven't played it), Just Cause 2, NWN 2: Platinum, Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, The Witcher: Enchanced Edition (original), X-COM: UFO Defense (original). That's just on Steam 0_0 (except the first two, which are GOG)

Here on GOG, I'm especially excited by Zeus/Poseidon and Fallout: Tactics, as well as Fallout 2. I've been really enjoying the new XCOM recently and I've heard Tactics might have some similar elements (even though it's more of a typical RPG than XCOM). Zeus/Poseidon sounds like Age of Mythology mixed with Civilization IV...if that's true than I'm almost seizing with excitement.

If it's that short, and not too hard, I'll give it a try.

Problem is, whenever I think of playing a puzzle game, I get reminded of all the other puzzle games I've sunk time into but am currently stuck on. Such as Toki Tori.

Yep, sounds about right lol. I would recommend that you play Deus Ex before any of the others, although that might just be because I've played that one the most of them all :-P

Deus Ex still feels fairly modern, despite it's dated graphics. Besides the Witcher, the others are going to feel more dated, especially in terms of the UI, which can be a frustrating roadblock when you're learning a new game. Deux Ex is still easy to pick up (I think) and the storyline is very interesting. Also, it happens to be the most innovative, in terms of your ability to control the story, game of the last decade. It makes today's FPSs look like kiddy toys: it simply has a depth that no game today can touch (even it's very solid sequel, Human Revolution, which I would also recommend if/when you have the cash)

I probably do need to find a system to play some of these old games: alphabetical order? release date? Otherwise, I'll just keep putting it off, playing something else!
I do seriously wonder if the way game design works today has somewhat "brainwashed" to be more ADD about games. I definitely feel like long text scrolls and having to read manuals is far more irritating than I remember it being 10-15 years ago, because games don't really require that anymore, since the story happens in the game events themselves most of the time.
Play it on the lowest settings: hell 800x600 if you have to (or whatever the lowest res is). Don't let your graphics rule when you play that game in particular, it's far too fantastic of an RPG to put it on the backburner. Example: I like the combat in that game quite a bit more than Skyrim, and the talent tree system is really fun to play around with. Also, the characters are far more realized than Skyrim can ever claim to be able to do.

I'm long, long overdue some post-apocalyptic open world adventuring, considering I own like 6 Fallout and Stalker games which I haven't yet played.

Also, the Total War series.

Dude, i'm on a 7600GT, way below the minimum requirements, the game doesn't display the floor texture properly [i mean, i can see the floor, way below where it's supposed to be], not to mention the 10FPS top i get. It's beyond unplayable at the moment, it has to wait. :)
When it comes to combat, i was never a fan of how Witcher did it, but then again, i think modern RPGs are far too combat oriented anyways. I'm more of a BAK guy myself, when every combat was a potential disaster, You wanted to avoid it as much as possible, at least in the beginning. I loved that.
Anyhow, I'm pretty much used to playing games on LOW@800x600, so that's not an issue really. As long as it's at least 20-25fps, i can play it, i did so with DXHR, more recently. I played Quake on the smallest window size, on a 386, finished it, enjoyed it, so yeah, graphical quality is not a problem at all.:>
Don't worry, one day, i will play TW2.:)