Aliasalpha: Well I just finished the demo.
Mostly okay, the stealth seems to work pretty well and the swinging and handling of the action events seems fairy good. I like the story so far (its STILL weird to think the same man was both Joker and Luke Skywalker) but I really don't like the combat, its pretty much the same as in that watchmen game that was on the 360 arcade recently.
I'll probably end up getting it since the combat isn't intolerable, just rather dull and I've played plenty worse games for the story
TheCheese33: You don't like the combat? I thought it was a lot better than the Watchmen brawling mechanics. It takes a bit to figure out how to do it smoothly and not punch the air several times like a moron, but once you get it, taking down goons can be very fun.
I dunno. Maybe it's due to the fact that the demo only gives you about 30 seconds of real combat time, but it seemed to me that it didn't really matter what button I pressed or which way I was facing; as long as I did -something-, Batman would take care of the rest.
In fact, I did an experiment just now - I went back to the first combat scene again, and I tried doing absolutely nothing but left-clicking; I didn't move, aim, dodge, counter or anything. I did take one hit from a thug, but that aside, Batman pretty much fought on his own, and I easily took down both groups pretty quickly. I even got some sort of "max combo bonus" that I didn't get when I was actually trying :/