Matruchus: Before I played Doom I ... definitely its Doom 1.
I totally forgot how good that game is and after I got it in the last sale its definitely the best ever shooter without unnecessary graphical extravagance. Just love it ...
Absolutely. No matter how many FPS I continue to get under my belt (I got away from playing the genre about when Half-Life 1 came out, and only have picked up and started playing everything I've missed over the past 15 years in the past 3 years) Doom1 is
still probably in the #1-3 best FPS of all time for me.
The best "newish" games I've played this year are Wasteland 2 and STASIS. and for FPS it's definitely Shadow Warrior 2013.
There are half a dozen others that I've played that are varying degrees of "older" that have been great too. Inquisitor, Gothic (which I'm only about 10 hours into, loving it so far...), Serious Sam 1st Encounter, S.T.A.L.K.E.R., Mount & Blade (just started it/have only a handful of hours into it too!! but wwowww~ fun!), and Dark Sun.
Most underwhelming/not as great to me as others hold it is definitely Dust: An Elysian Tail (not that it's not a fun and pretty platformer that I'm enjoying quite a bit. Haven't finished it yet either!)