F4LL0UT: In my opinion it's a brilliant but almost universally misunderstood film. It physically hurts me when I see people mistake its clearly intentional trashiness and cheesiness for regular movie badness. awalterj: My sentiment exactly, Starship Troopers is satire of the finest. The problem with satire of the finest is that it's so unflinchingly straightforward that many will miss out on it being satire entirely - because satire doesn't try to be funny. I don't know how many young people joined the military after seeing that movie but I'm quite sure the number is high.
On the technical side, the movie is just as excellent. The CGI effects are convincing and still look better than most films released today. Soundtrack, costumes, props, design, everything is top notch.
To be honest i think it's very much on the tightrope. It's more ambiguous than mere satire, it's more like high self-awareness, almost a hommage to heroic war movies but without their naivety and 'innocence'. Like, "we want to do a badass heroic war movie but we are too intelligent to have the required beliefs for that, so, let's be transparent about the silliness that the codes imply".
In other words, i find it closer to WH40000 than to a pure satire. Satire focuses on "it's dumb". WH40000 and Starship Trooper sound more like "dumbness is the door to coolness, let's not hide that".