Ok, I've finally seen it (a bit late to the party, I know). I'll have to precess this for a while, but here are my immediate thoughts.
SPOILERS FOLLOW!!!
It's better than Force Awakens (low set bar that one, but still). Not as good as Rogue One, not to mention the original trilogy. Still, I mostly enjoyed it.
The good stuff.
The opening, although the set up is total rip-off of Empire Strikes Back (more on that in a moment), is a really great sequence.
Hamill is great and has more to work with here than I think he ever did, let's him show more of his acting talent. Even if I'm not entirely on board with Luke's character in these new movies Hamill is so good he sells it. And I liked the Yoda cameo. A lot of good stuff, both funny and poignant there on that planet. And elsewhere Poe had more to do this time, and defiantely is my favourite of the new cast. He's really the only one that has any charisma or personality.
Overall, most of the film, despite the flaws I'll go into, was fun to watch, with some really good visuals.
Now the bad stuff.
It's overlong. It drags at times, and most of everything to do with Finn and his mission is really totaly pointless. Every time we cut back to him and that casino planet I'd groan and wish we could stay with Luke. And Rey, I guess, though Rey is still mostly bland and boring. I so wish they cast someone else in that role.
BB-8 is ridiculous in this movie. That droid is awesome at everything, he can do everything. Why does anynone build giant AT-ATs and battle droids and has armies of troopers? Just build an army of BB-8s! They are the ultimate weapon!
Leia's scene. The space scene. My god, I have not laughed this much in a cinema in a long time. Terrible and hilarious.
Finn's suicide run. Would have been great... if it had the proper conclusion. Saving him was lame, anticlimactic and made no sense. Yay, let's save one guy and lose the battle and doom us all, including that one guy!
This time they are fortunately not ripping-off one movie wholesale, but still there is a shitload of scenes ripped straight from the original trilogy. It's not just similiar, it's shot for shot, line for line. I get that it's intentional, but whatever they were going for, I still found it jarring.
Snoke goes out like a bitch. We still don't know who or what he was, and now we're out of any decent villains. Because Kylo... I'm sorry, he still sucks. Maybe not as much as in the Force Awakens, but as a main villain, he is still weak.
And there was no reason admiral Hondo couldn't just tell Poe her plan and avoid a lot of mess.
And finally - how in the fuck did we even get here? Apparently the First Order took over the Galaxy OFF SCREEN. Between movies. Even though this movie begins pretty much immediately after the previous one. And that one ended with First Order getting their asses kicked. Man, the Republic really sucks. Maybe we should stop rebuilding it.
Post edited December 19, 2017 by Breja