yesterday i started to play the ps3 exclusive game [url=http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/uncharted/images/1/12/U-857.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20091017023654]2.

wtf, seriously! how and why should that submarine be there, that just destroys the serious atmosphere of the game. which was created before. clearly the devs, who are praised for their great games, didn't do much during the development. as otherwise they just would see how stupid it is to place that submarine into the jungle.

video games are full of unreliasm, but it mostly is intended and essential for the game itself. like sorcery and dragons in tes games. but this is one example which shouldn't be in that game at all and its not a bug. so aside from theories about a submarine appearance in the jungle, do you remember similar cases in other games?

Asking why that would be there, is like asking why wouldn't you piss on people on postal 2. :P Why not? :P

How does this not make sense to you?
It was a flying submarine, it just lost its wings.

Personally, I have a real problem with silent protagonists, specially on JRPGs. Main case being Chrno Trigger, I know it's supposed to be a masterpiece and whatnot but I can't get over the silent protagonist thing. People talking to the main character and acting like he replied is something that gets on my nerves a lot.

yeah it was one the flying subs from new swabia :)

Maybe the devs had seen Murphy's War.

interesting, i mostly enjoy that silence and hate to hear my character talk.

^legit.

Out of bounds submarine from Silent Hunter 3. That game was pretty buggy.

I loved the way Golden Sun did it, all you can do is reply yes or no. The third game added emotion icons as responses.

Your expectations are very off, that submarine is far from being the least realistic thing in the game and very much fits the overall style. Plus from what I recall the game actually acknowledges the submarine to be an uncommon thing, that basically makes it okay in my book.

I can't say things like that bothers me, it's so rare that something appears that completely takes me out of suspension of disbelief. That said, I can't stand invisible walls. The main reason is not realism but the fact that I have expectations of possible discoveries that then are turned into disappointments.

On JRPGs, I hardly ever identify the main character as "mine". He's just one more character, and seem him mute bothers me.

Matter of taste I guess.

for me its not about the ability to reply during a conversation, which is nice as long you only read the reply but don't hear any voice. i don't like to hear any voices from my own character. just play indiana jones emperors tomb and you'll quickly learn to enjoy quite chracters.
yes thats a nice info, but just can not apply here, if you look at the pictures that i linked.