It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionSecret Hitler #2 - Everybody is a Star(1694 posts)(1694 posts)
(1694 posts)
Pages:
1
25
50
75
100
102
103
104
105
106
113
This is my favourite topic
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: You're saying you are F, Trent is F, ZFR was L?
I'm saying Trent and I are F, yes.
ZFR? Well, that's up for you to decide. He's not Hitler, but he could be fascist or he could be liberal.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: You're saying you are F, Trent is F, ZFR was L?
avatar
PookaMustard: I'm saying Trent and I are F, yes.
ZFR? Well, that's up for you to decide. He's not H, but he could be f or he could be liberal.
But ZFR being F would mean that trent is H and SPF and supplementscene are liberal and we might actually win.

Is it possible?

No - why would ZFR have twice failed to nominate Trent as chancellor for the win? I'm sure he could have.
Posted March 06, 2019
Oh. I see. If ZFR was L then that's the second L out of the game.

So if ZFR's F then it's safe for me to vote yes to SirP/supplementscene.

If ZFR's L then the only chance is to vote against the Fs (without knowing actually what it is they're voting for) three times in a row, and have all the other Ls vote with me, without knowing what it is they need to vote against or that they can trust me. Unless blotunga was F.

Is THAT possible?

Lifthrasil argued to eliminate me, but said that blotunga would be alright if not Joe. ZFR directly asked for his opinion, it seems like unnecessary risk.


I think we lost.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: Why weren't you interested in hearing Trent's reason for killing ZFR?
Because of his moustache twirling, cape swooshing, cackling admission that he lied.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: Why weren't you interested in hearing Trent's reason for killing ZFR?
avatar
SirPrimalform: Because of his moustache twirling, cape swooshing, cackling admission that he lied.
I see it now. I was optimistically imagining that he had taken my side in the Lifthrasil/Joe conflict and was guessing that ZFR was H-bomb.

I'm still hoping that he'll come back and make it all better.
Posted March 06, 2019
OK re-read SPF government. I think SPF is Liberal. SPF declared he drew LLF and passed Lift LF in order to test him.

I don't think Hitler or regular Fascist would admit they drew LLF because it means they couldn't do anything other than pass Liberal policy. They'd claim LFF to say LAMIST I had a choice of passing Fascist policy yet I didn't. Regular Fascist would probably also pass LL in order to not confirm the other Liberal player.

SPF voted against Lift and Blotungas government I asked why to which he answered:

"I suspect Blotunga of being fascist. I'm not also especially convinced about Pooka being liberal and thus I find his investigation result makes him look worse in my eyes rather than Blotunga better."

So he is either suspicious of Confirmed Fascist Pooka early or distancing? I think SPF is Liberal.

Confirmed Liberal ZFR stated on SPF: I have metagame reasons to believe he's Liberal, but I'm not taking the risk.

SPF also scumread Joe numerous times.

For me it's goto SPFs Presidency or Lifts Presidency to hopefully pass our 5th L.

avatar
ZFR: That's a risk I don't want to take. So can we have a quick poll.

@everyone, please answer how you'd vote
Chancellor Lift
Chancellor scene

I'm Yes to both
avatar
trentonlf: I’m probably no to both. As I told Joe earlier I found Lift to be the scum between them and I don’t see a reason to take a chance on puting possible scum into the chancellor position. As for Scene I have voted no for him already for president and see no reason to vote yes for chancellor. I’d say put me in as chancellor and I’ll pass an L if it’s passed to me.
Note Trent stearing me out of government. So I can't be Hitler or Fascist.

Trent also voted against my Presidency and accused me of being Scum on Day 1.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
Lifthrasil: Mostly because he is giving me no vibes at all.
Attachments:
1106722_22618_po.jpg (90 Kb)
Posted March 06, 2019
I've got two pointed questions:

1 Why would Trent say this? -

avatar
trentonlf: I lied, I never had the intention to shoot Joe or Pooka.
2 Why didn't Trent eliminate Lifthrasil?
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: I've got two pointed questions:

1 Why would Trent say this? -

avatar
trentonlf: I lied, I never had the intention to shoot Joe or Pooka.
avatar
JoeSapphire: 2 Why didn't Trent eliminate Lifthrasil?
Presumably because he felt it was so transparently fascist that he didn't see any point in trying to conceal it further.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: I've got two pointed questions:

1 Why would Trent say this? -

2 Why didn't Trent eliminate Lifthrasil?
avatar
SirPrimalform: Presumably because he felt it was so transparently f that he didn't see any point in trying to conceal it further.
And why name Pooka and Joe?


With regard to the second question - is there any particular reason why he'd choose ZFR over Lifthrasil? Lifthrasil's the one that was to be elected president by ZFR's plan. ZFR had even suggested having someone-who-wasn't-ZFR as chancellor if Lifthrasil suspected him of being H.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: I've got two pointed questions:

1 Why would Trent say this? -

avatar
trentonlf: I lied, I never had the intention to shoot Joe or Pooka.
avatar
JoeSapphire: 2 Why didn't Trent eliminate Lifthrasil?
If I had just been in government with ZFR I would have shot Lift instead. I didn’t want a confirmed Liberal in the next government.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
SirPrimalform: Presumably because he felt it was so transparently f that he didn't see any point in trying to conceal it further.
avatar
JoeSapphire: And why name Pooka and Joe?

With regard to the second question - is there any particular reason why he'd choose ZFR over Lifthrasil?
Because I'm term-locked now and ZFR wasn't.

Other question: what are you trying to achieve? You can't sow any doubt in any Liberal about the alignment of Pooka and trent. So why try?
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
SirPrimalform: Presumably because he felt it was so transparently f that he didn't see any point in trying to conceal it further.
avatar
JoeSapphire: And why name Pooka and Joe?

With regard to the second question - is there any particular reason why he'd choose ZFR over Lifthrasil? Lifthrasil's the one that was to be elected president by ZFR's plan. ZFR had even suggested having someone-who-wasn't-ZFR as chancellor if Lifthrasil suspected him of being H.
So you're implying that Trent is Lift's scumbuddy and this is why he didn't kill Lift? But ZFR isn't term locked, where as Lift is. The only thing that doesn't sit well with me is that Trent doesn't accuse ZFR/Lift of being Fascist, which seems like the best move as it blocks Lift from government. So maybe you're right but you're the one who knew Blotunga wasn't Hitler before Zeo told us. Only a fascist could know that and I think it was a slip on your part.

I really don't believe you're Liberal because yet again you've made another post twisting Lift's words below. In the very unlikely event you are Liberal it must mean SPF is the only president you can consider. I'm in 2 minds whether I'm going to go with SPFs plan myself as Lift seems a better bet for me.

You nearly fooled me a few times Joe and you may yet win but I just hope we have 5 Liberals to stop that

avatar
JoeSapphire: Lifthrasil argued to eliminate me, but said that blotunga would be alright if not Joe. ZFR directly asked for his opinion, it seems like unnecessary risk.

I think we lost.
I re-read this. Lift in his post stressed the importance of shooting a confirmed Liberal, stating we would be weakened otherwise. He had a very strong preference for you. He wasn't pushing for Blotunga and did say it was a risk. He said he'd be fine with either Blotunga or RTSCV if we're aiming for Hitler but said he preferred a confirmed Fascist. This is how a Liberal would play it Joe.

ZFR did make a mistake not going for a confirmed Liberal but hopefully we got a fascist. Blotunga did accuse Scene, ZFR and RTCSV as plotting against him at this stage. And I know 2 of those are Liberal and I know RTSCV told the truth about drawing FFF
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
Lifthrasil: Because I'm term-locked now and ZFR wasn't.

Other question: what are you trying to achieve? You can't sow any doubt in any Liberal about the alignment of Pooka and trent. So why try?
Because I understood what Trent's doing: Trying to make it look like Pooka and Trent and Joe are all one team.

I'm not trying to argue that Pooka and Trent are liberal. At first I was until I understood what they were getting at.


avatar
Lifthrasil: Because I'm term-locked now and ZFR wasn't.
What would ZFR be saying if he were here now?

avatar
ZFR: So, assuming blotunga is not H after all (looks like it from Joe's and Pooka's reactions):

trent is chosen and shoots Joe or Pooka (my preference here is Joe, since there is a slight chance he's H; Pooka definitely isn't).

After that you [lifthrasil] choose me as Chancellor. We have a good chance of passing one of those 3 Ls, and if you get FFF we can veto it.
If you still have doubts I could be H, I'm open to suggestions of whom you think you should choose instead. If I were to pick an alternative I'd go with scene. Given the events, and despite him being his usual self, I think scene is Liberal too.
But I'd rather you pick me.

The only risk is that trent is H (he's definitely NOT vanilla fascist: he can't be due to him picking you as his chancellor in the second government) and executes me or you. But I doubt that's the case. Of the two, I'd pick trent over SPF.

Thoughts?
He'd be saying "why are we even considering an SPF-supplementscene government? Skip to Lifthrasil as president.

Incidentally I wonder if he'd be reconsidering Joe's alignment once the Trent-is-not-vanilla-F-because-he-picked-Liberal-Lifthrasil-for-second-government argument turned out to be wrong. Doubt it. :p


So, with that in mind Lifthrasil should have come to mind as an execution target. No? ZFR proposed Lifthrasil-supplementscene as an alternative to the Lifthrasil-ZFR government.


avatar
supplementscene:
avatar
SirPrimalform:
I was about to ask you both "considering that you both say you trust Lifthrasil but aren't sure you can trust each other what the hell are you doing going through with the government you've proposed?"

But I see how supplementscene's just said he might consider going to a Lifthrasil-Supplmentscene government.

How would you feel about that SirP?


avatar
supplementscene: I really don't believe you're Liberal because yet again you've made another post twisting Lift's words below. In the very unlikely event you are Liberal it must mean SPF is the only president you can consider. I'm in 2 minds whether I'm going to go with SPFs plan myself as Lift seems a better bet for me.

You nearly fooled me a few times Joe and you may yet win but I just hope we have 5 Liberals to stop that

avatar
JoeSapphire: Lifthrasil argued to eliminate me, but said that blotunga would be alright if not Joe. ZFR directly asked for his opinion, it seems like unnecessary risk.

I think we lost.
avatar
supplementscene: I re-read this. Lift in his post stressed the importance of shooting a confirmed Liberal, stating we would be weakened otherwise. He had a very strong preference for you. He wasn't pushing for Blotunga and did say it was a risk. He said he'd be fine with either Blotunga or RTSCV if we're aiming for H but said he preferred a confirmed F. This is how a Liberal would play it Joe.

ZFR did make a mistake not going for a confirmed Liberal but hopefully we got a f. Blotunga did accuse Scene, ZFR and RTCSV as plotting against him at this stage. And I know 2 of those are Liberal and I know RTSCV told the truth about drawing FFF
^ yeah, that's what I said too "blotunga would be alright if not Joe" = "Lift had a strong preference for Joe, but he'd be fine with either blotunga or rtcvb."

No mistakes, no twisting.


avatar
supplementscene: In the very unlikely event you are Liberal it must mean SPF is the only president you can consider.
You're right. The only real chance I have is that neither of you are F, and that blotunga was, which isn't impossible, but then why would Trent have done what he did? The other chance I have is the 2/8 chance if I can convince you/SirP, rtcvb, and flubbucket to vote no on the next three governments. Which is no chance at all.

2 negligible chances. I like those odds.
Posted March 06, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: 2 Why didn't Trent eliminate Lifthrasil?
avatar
SirPrimalform: Presumably because he felt it was so transparently fascist that he didn't see any point in trying to conceal it further.
Suggesting a possible 4-4 and the game's over due to loss of the majority vote.

But i'm on the fence on that and i'm sure it's still 5-3. Have to see in the next set of governments.



So, my new strategy starting now: Vote no on any combination using Joe, Pooka and trent.

Remember starting now: Veto power if FFF happens. Probably need clarification with Zeo. I'm certain veto request will happen in PM, and then it's posted in the post.
Pages:
1
25
50
75
100
102
103
104
105
106
113
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionSecret Hitler #2 - Everybody is a Star(1694 posts)(1694 posts)
(1694 posts)