It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Hello, I have recently created a question in the Witcher forum to ask about a game specific question. I have discovered the solution now but I cannot mark my own post as the solution :-/

Is this deliberate or do I need to have enough reputation or similar to do this?
avatar
TheDcoder: Is this deliberate or do I need to have enough reputation or similar to do this?
It is deliberate, as marking a post as a solution gives the owner of the post a rep boost. An obvious exploit if you could mark your own post as the solution - not that anyone cares about forum reputation anymore these days, but the protection is still in place.
Post edited May 25, 2018 by WinterSnowfall
I see, might be unfortunate for those have found solution for their problem themselves.
It's not actually unfortunate. Even when a solution is given, sometimes it stops working later. So the original solution isn't as important so much as the topic for anybody looking for possibilities. But that's life in general, too, isn't it?

I've noticed when people claim to have solved their own problems but do not detail how they did it, and then others come along and ask why details weren't given. But the OP never returns to say.
Post edited May 25, 2018 by thomq
deleted
avatar
WinterSnowfall: It is deliberate, as marking a post as a solution gives the owner of the post a rep boost. An obvious exploit if you could mark your own post as the solution - not that anyone cares about forum reputation anymore these days, but the protection is still in place.
avatar
Fairfox: gogie could code it so taht markin' your own post as solution gives you naaazin'

.....
...lmfao!!!111111beeofknees!!11its funny because they CANNOT!!!11
I don't see why you couldn't.... HOWEVER you can't get a rep boost from it.

But meh, that's my opinion.
avatar
TheDcoder: Is this deliberate or do I need to have enough reputation or similar to do this?
avatar
WinterSnowfall: It is deliberate, as marking a post as a solution gives the owner of the post a rep boost. An obvious exploit if you could mark your own post as the solution - not that anyone cares about forum reputation anymore these days, but the protection is still in place.
But there is nothing to stop a CONSPIRACY!
Two (or more) members could enter an agreement to post questions and solutions in tandem. If it were possible to delete a post, this could even be done whilst removing the evidence …
avatar
TheDcoder: Hello, I have recently created a thread in the Witcher forum to ask about a game specific question. I have discovered the solution now but I cannot mark my own post as the solution :-/

Is this deliberate or do I need to have enough reputation or similar to do this?
As others have already mentioned - you can't.
And yes, it kinda sucks, but is also understandable - for the very reason, WinterSnowfall has stated.

I recently also had a "Question"-thread. And I also found the answer to my question on my own.

My first impulse was to just select one of the other comments in the thread as the solution, but then I decided against it, for two reasons:

1) None of these comments gave the actual solution.
2) It would have been unfair, to randomly choose one comment over the others.

So, that thread will also remain "unsolved".
It's a pity, but also the fairest solution.

However, the thing, that irks me much more, is when someone opens a "question"-thread, then gets an actual answer (or answers) that solves the problem - and then doesn't mark the (first/most) helpful comment as the solution.

I mean...why set it up as a "question"-thread, if you don't intend to return to it, or to honor the fellow GOGger, who helped you?
avatar
rtcvb32: I don't see why you couldn't.... HOWEVER you can't get a rep boost from it.
A very valid point, but I doubt GOG will ever change how it works now. Not unless they replace the entire forum at one point that is.
avatar
scientiae: But there is nothing to stop a CONSPIRACY!
Two (or more) members could enter an agreement to post questions and solutions in tandem. If it were possible to delete a post, this could even be done whilst removing the evidence …
I have this naive belief that people have better things to do with their lives, but of course you are right :).
Post edited May 25, 2018 by WinterSnowfall
Didn't we have a thread where a staff member marked their own post as the solution?

Or something similar?

I can't find it right off because google is picking up on all the "No posts in this topic were marked as the solution yet" that are in the forums.
avatar
drmike: Didn't we have a thread where a staff member marked their own post as the solution?
I highlighted the crucial bit for you.

;)
avatar
BreOl72: I highlighted the crucial bit for you.
You forgot this bit:

Or something similar?
I don't recall the exact thread and what happened so I went looking. That's why I had a disclaimer on it.

The reason why I went looking was because I believe it developed into a rather lengthy discussion on the topic.

edit: Thank you though for trying.
Post edited May 25, 2018 by drmike
avatar
rtcvb32: I don't see why you couldn't.... HOWEVER you can't get a rep boost from it.
avatar
WinterSnowfall: A very valid point, but I doubt GOG will ever change how it works now. Not unless they replace the entire forum at one point that is.
avatar
scientiae: But there is nothing to stop a CONSPIRACY!
Two (or more) members could enter an agreement to post questions and solutions in tandem. If it were possible to delete a post, this could even be done whilst removing the evidence …
avatar
WinterSnowfall: I have this naive belief that people have better things to do with their lives, but of course you are right :).
One could even imagine creating multiple accounts, to self-aggrandize …sorta like Twitter claques & Facebook cliques.
avatar
scientiae: One could even imagine creating multiple accounts, to self-aggrandize …sorta like Twitter claques & Facebook cliques.
Which explains this whole thread very nicely.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyNyHark4xk
avatar
scientiae: But there is nothing to stop a CONSPIRACY!
Two (or more) members could enter an agreement to post questions and solutions in tandem. If it were possible to delete a post, this could even be done whilst removing the evidence …
...
...
One could even imagine creating multiple accounts, to self-aggrandize …sorta like Twitter claques & Facebook cliques.
You know the old saying - "To catch a rep-cheater, you have to think like a rep-cheater".

;)