Posted July 04, 2015

Krypsyn
The Anti-Hippie
Registered: Oct 2008
From United States

Sage103082
Kitten Tamer: 8
Registered: Mar 2014
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015
Giggles. Seems a bit OMGUS but ok. I can see some of the reasons for Kypsyns votes. So I am not going to jump on him for it. As of right now I am more inclined to see how things go before voting on anyone seriously. I did not vote you. I merely pointed out something that bothered me. It is a bit nice to know it hit a sore spot. Noted. Though from something you said I am unsure your alignment yet as we need to see more information and how things play out.
which reminds me UNOVTE CSVPG
which reminds me UNOVTE CSVPG

RWarehall
Ja'loja!
Registered: Jan 2012
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015
And nothing too damning for you. Just pointing out how there have been a lot of little things far more serious than the words "Us town" to avoid third-person.
What really bothers me most is that this comes right after you say everyone should pile-on and vote for me, but "conveniently" my post is called out as suspicious without a vote. As if this is an attempt to push a wagon without getting on it, leaving plausible deniability when I flip town...
What really bothers me most is that this comes right after you say everyone should pile-on and vote for me, but "conveniently" my post is called out as suspicious without a vote. As if this is an attempt to push a wagon without getting on it, leaving plausible deniability when I flip town...

Sage103082
Kitten Tamer: 8
Registered: Mar 2014
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015
I am sorry if I upset you but I am going to point out anything I find off. I did not find it enough to vote for you nor did I ask anyone else to place a vote on you. I only pointed out that to me it didnt feel right.

bler144
μαϊμού
Registered: Dec 2013
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015

I know I'm the newbie, but I think everyone is being obfuscatory to some extent, whether it's through posting unrelated links, or making a charge just to draw a reaction, etc. It's unlikely more than 1-2 players here haven't at least been blowing fog on the mirror at least some of the time. For me, at times the zig/zagging has probably been accidental or inexperience admittedly, and at other times more intentional. And at other times being half-asleep and half-drunk.
While I think I've latched on to a particular player as my north star here for general direction in how I might like my play to evolve, I do have to say that I actually agree with Kryp on this post: https://www.gog.com/forum/general/mafia_28_everyday_life_in_grand_oak_gallows/post232
Not, per se, that I think people take it too seriously, but that we overestimate our intuition in a game where random variability is high. Especially as we don't even know the roles/factions in play. And we tend to remember the times we were right and underplay the times we are wrong. "I voted wrong the first 4 nights, but that fifth night, by gum, I was right! I knew it all along!"
Perhaps trent/yog's past acrimony is serving them for cover here - they came out hard against each other early. On the other hand if it turns out the third faction is vikings, well, then we know who tipped their hand.
The stagecraft and the dance make it fun, but presumably all we'll really know come day 2 is body count as we try and suss out what in that was feint, what was WIFOM, etc. etc. Someone may well guess the right target for entirely the wrong reasons.
Maybe Bookwyrm is begging for an investigation, but if the game is unbalanced as it's been described and there are insane cops (I wiki'ed it - I'm totes pro now) that would seem an overly bold early move, and would tend to backfire, since you'd essentially have a double negative, no?
I'd still personally prefer to sit no vote, but if people think there's something to be sussed out of a good ol' hanging (even just moving the game forward I'm willing to play along.
That said, my general leaning on who to vote for if I do vote really hasn't changed that much. I still think Kryp is hiding something significant and that the early self-vote was intentional as a feint, and with agentcarr now on board but leonard stepping out, I'd tend to either go back to my initial vote for Kryp, as much as I enjoy the links, or to leonard who's going to be functionally anti-town in absence regardless of what his role actual is.
Of the folks bickering, sure it's likely at least one (or more) of them is guilty and the raging is cover, but I don't really buy that any of them have slipped in a way that we could detect at this point - though a hunch could still turn out to be correct of course, oh, say maybe 29% of the time.

Krypsyn
The Anti-Hippie
Registered: Oct 2008
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015


Sage103082
Kitten Tamer: 8
Registered: Mar 2014
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015

Krypsyn
The Anti-Hippie
Registered: Oct 2008
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015
Oh noes! How will I ever compete with the pink hair?!
Anyone have any spare hemlock laying around? The way Shakespeare seems to have it laying everywhere in his plays, it must grow on trees! Is it like a carrot or something? I will poison the rival princess with carrots!
Hopefully, she isn't in another castle...
Anyone have any spare hemlock laying around? The way Shakespeare seems to have it laying everywhere in his plays, it must grow on trees! Is it like a carrot or something? I will poison the rival princess with carrots!
Hopefully, she isn't in another castle...

Sage103082
Kitten Tamer: 8
Registered: Mar 2014
From United States
Posted July 04, 2015
She is always in another castle or she just wants to be friends. What is with this friend zone thing? Come on. I battle and work my way through dungeon after dungeon just to get a peak on the cheek and then spend 39.99 to do it all over again with different backgrounds.

Krypsyn
The Anti-Hippie
Registered: Oct 2008
From United States
Posted July 05, 2015
Inorite? Total BS.

Vitek
Master of Karate and friendship for everyone
Registered: Apr 2009
From British Indian Ocean Territory
Posted July 05, 2015
V-v-v-v-v-v-votecount
Bookwyrm – 2 – trentonlf, yogsloth
yogsloth – 2 – JMich, Bookwyrm
cristigale – 1 – Leonard
dedoporno – 1 – flubbucket
no-lynch – 1 - bler
RWarehall – 1 – Krypsyn
Sage – 1 – Rwarehall
not voting – 5 - agentcarr, dedoporno, CSPVG, cristigale, Sage
Bookwyrm and yogsloth are closest to lynch with 2 votes.
Deadline was not deemed neccessary yet.
Bookwyrm – 2 – trentonlf, yogsloth
yogsloth – 2 – JMich, Bookwyrm
cristigale – 1 – Leonard
dedoporno – 1 – flubbucket
no-lynch – 1 - bler
RWarehall – 1 – Krypsyn
Sage – 1 – Rwarehall
not voting – 5 - agentcarr, dedoporno, CSPVG, cristigale, Sage
Bookwyrm and yogsloth are closest to lynch with 2 votes.
Deadline was not deemed neccessary yet.

bler144
μαϊμού
Registered: Dec 2013
From United States
Posted July 05, 2015
Watching what everyone else is doing, I'm a bit skeptical we'll get any serious votes (or bring in non-voters off the fence) until there's an actual deadline on the table.
So uh, having said that this is a totally serious, well-reasoned decision that I will absolutely not be changing between now and any future deadline:
Unvote no-lynch
Vote Sage for president, 2016
So uh, having said that this is a totally serious, well-reasoned decision that I will absolutely not be changing between now and any future deadline:
Unvote no-lynch
Vote Sage for president, 2016

Bookwyrm627
ADD Jumping Bean
Registered: Nov 2013
From United States

Krypsyn
The Anti-Hippie
Registered: Oct 2008
From United States
Posted July 05, 2015

yogsloth
GRAAAAAAH!!!!!
Registered: Dec 2013
From United States