Bookwyrm627: I wish I had more spaghetti.
Granted: The Flying Spaghetti Monster comes into being and sticks its noodly appendage at you, and you are given tons of spaghetti. However, you are now bound by your new pastafarian beliefs to cover your head with a colander whenever you go out in public (including on your driver's license picture).
(I know somebody already took this one, but I really wanted it.)
Vnlr: I wish someone would make a Sword of The Stars III and made it work right ...
Granted, but it takes a while. Sword of The Stars III is first released (without any mention of Early Access) in a state that isn't yet playable, then the game gets a huge number of patches, eventually making the game complete and functional. Unfortunately, by then the game has such a bad reputation that nobody wants it anymore.
I wish for some company I have never heard of to release a good Wizardry-like on this site.