As to our PMs and role claims...
Look, I just don't want to win that way. We are winning right now through logical deduction without resorting to such cheese. I'd prefer we keep it that way.

Hello everyone, just a quick update for everybody so y'all are in the know: I am in the middle of packing because I am moving states next Tuesday (so right as this game day ends), thus I will be available a little bit more haphazardly than usual for the remainder of this week. I shall return later today with thoughts.

right yes it was a more or less rhetorical question that you encouraging people to ask by all means. Good And Cool.

---

why am I getting all the sass?

---

just that RW was voting to self-preserve. He was heaviest wagon and I'd just made a super compelling demand for blood. Scum!RW could sit where he was with two scums being the heaviest and best supported wagons, or he could start damage control.

But, looking at it again this does not look very likely. I'm pretty much ready to dismiss this theory entirely.

When I asked it it was rhetorical. My encouragement was more just a send up of your request that people not answer the question that you imagined I asked.

EBWOP: "encourage people to ANSWER by all means." Messing up language while being super bitchy sarcastic is not a good look for me friends. Kinda hate myself right now.

---

not particularly. I see you're going for catte, but I don't think he lies about whether he was attending the game or not. I think this is the sort of thing catte does not lie about. The light may have gone on, but if he says he didn't read the thread we can trust that.

Doesn't mean he can't be mafia.

Yeah, I guess from your point of view bucktooth was more of a thing than my point of view. tbh I hadn't really read either of your bucktooth pushes, and I only had time to check the game very briefly in the run up to end of day. I saw bucktooth was the new wagon, thought 'he could be mafia, sure' and voted, then thought "I hope whatever HypersomniacLive has written there is good stuff and makes sense."

I picked up that your argument was to do with tone difference between this game and others I think?

Anyway I kinda thought that the bucktooth wagon was last-minute panic that in the light of Day might not be seen as worth pursuing, if it had failed. But actually you had put in more work than I'm giving you credit for. Sorry.


---

this is toDay you're talking about? The four people being the ones who weren't on buck's wagon?


is it worth trying this sentence again? :)

---

you did ask it! I know I shouldn't be engaging with this because you're just going to keep responding and really there's no point to any of it but what's the point in me saying "don't answer that" for you to say "do answer that" for me to say "i think it's dangerous" for you to say "well I didn't want people to answer it" just say "yeah let's not answer it Joe MAYBE HAS A POINT HE MIGHT NOT BE A BIG CHUMPY DOOFUS LIKE WE THOUGHT HE WAS ALL THIS TIME"?

ok I get you. your top four prettiest princeess are Catte, Dessimu (hi dess), Razza and babark, fifth place is me, which puts Ambiti0nZ in 6th place which makes him pretty much town for you considering there's only 9 other players.

I stole this question off someone from mafia universe, but if you could blast 5 peole out the airlock now, and if any scums remained on deack you'd lose, would you go with those 5? Catte, Dess, Razza, Babark, me?

EBWOP

Everyone is still sleepy from the Night and a bit shocked over the loss of Max. Those gravestones really don't look funny. They are not the kind of graves you dig up to get bones for voodoo spells, but the kind of graves that means someone died here. So no one is really willing to cast the first stone. Talking and thinking seems to be on the agenda instead of wild voting. Like in an adventure game, really.

Official Vote Count

No one is voting.

Not woken up yet: detective_razza

The Day has started yesterday. Please return to the game.

+1. I have leftover tabs all the time and on various devices but it doesn't mean I'm online and actively reading the thread. I'm pretty sure the same applies to other, especially people who work on a computer. To be perfectly honest I've always disliked that badge being used to persecute people for not participating in a game :/

hey folks!
apologies for my slight absence, i was a little busy IRL but i did manage to get through the thread and have a look.
i also apologise for not voting, i thought i’d be able to get a vote in before i left but i didn’t and then by the time i got home and back on here it was night phase.

anyways, i’m back B) i see we had a last minute vote on bucktooth and it seemed to be pretty successful?
please correct me if i’m wrong.

Wrong about what?

New page bug test

I must say I was expecting more activity than this - my fellow townies, let's not get complacent/lazy because we nailed a scum on D1. This is the time we need to push forward, control the thread.

From toDay's posts:


Yep, you're firmly in the PoE.

Are you ever going to reply to my post #346, or are you planning to just go through D2 dodging it?



TIL. I didn't know that the GOG online status feature behaves this way; bleh. I expected to hear something like you thought you had some time, came on, and then something came up and you had to leave suddenly, and it'd have been fine because rule #3.
I'm pretty certain, however, that we've never had this discussion before - if I'd known about it, I wouldn't have the thoughts I had at EoD1.



Talk to me about the rest in the list. Do you think any of them are going to self-resolve, and if yes, which ones? What about the rest? Remember, we only have two mislynches if there are two more mafia.


Why do you frame it as him having a special role that makes him more valuable than the goon? Doesn't any role tramp goon? Being a stump-maker doesn't count.

On to my second point - as I said in my first post of the Day, we didn't really have the votes to lunch RWarehall in the final hours of EoD1. So, given that he's generally pro-Lynch, and had made posts #361, #371 and #375, do you think that he'd try and save his scum-buddy in a scenario where he doesn't have a special role as you said? I mean, we barely made the votes to get a wagon over, and that was with his vote; you think he'd risk standing out as the one who let it go to NL, and thus his own lunch on D2?



Please elaborate, how does any of this make you town?


He had said he had a scum-read on bucktoothgamer back in post #282, right behind babark.


Who all are you counting as said people to reach a total of seven without bucktoothgamer?



Then why did you bring it up?


So you asked LordCephy to talk about his read of FrostburnPhoenix as an experienced player but didn't read it, you were planning to read RWarehall and me but didn't do it, and you didn't read my bucktoothgamer pushes and have no idea if they made sense...
This sounds awfully like you made zero effort to game-solve after you formed your initial pool of people to take for the D1 lunch.

In the PoE you stay.


Perhaps you're projecting your last-minute panic to be on the right wagon...?



I don't follow - if you managed to get through the thread and have a look, why are you uncertain about the D1 Lunch outcome?


I'll check back in later, have some stuff from D1 I'd like to go over with people, and I hope that, by that time, ZFR, Dessimu and Abmiti0nZ will have made an appearance and some contributions.

Ehwhat?
So because it's not plausible (in any way I see) that you're scum, and because you got lucky with starting a wagon, suddenly you're king and everyone answers to you?

Are you seriously aggressively telling me to give evidence of your aggressiveness towards everyone in a post where you're being aggressive to everyone? Can you see why I skipped that question when you asked it the first time around? Apparently this is your normal way of addressing people in Mafia games, but I gotta say, I'm certainly not used to it.


As for ideas based off of the sequence of votes (can't really be with any certainty, because the rushed timing at the end seems to have caused confusion), my simplistic reading of it would be that there's at least one mafia among catte, Joe and dedo.