Thanks, I just couldn't tell if my earth shatteringly important post above was lost in the void forever or if it was just waiting to show up on the next page.

I don't really have much to add at the moment. I guess PoE:

Catte = town
ZFR = town
Joe = almost certainly town

Dogmaus = town vibes

Leoric = townish? Not much to go on
Dedo = Leaning hmm?
Cadaver = confused but earnest?

Flub = hammering a bit sus, probably not scum with Lift
Lift = kind of off, probably not scum with flub
Bookwyrm = votes Joe (not sus) and basically ignores all evidence that suggests Joe is town (sus). Maybe not paying attention? But he picked up on ZFR's neutral theory.

I think I've talked myself into changing my vote to

vote Bookwyrm

Interesting reaction to being doubted. I am aware, what you wrote as your reason. That doesn't mean it's your true motive. Scum lie in this game, you know? So please explain to me, what exactly is scummy about my wondering about your alignment?

Is 3 goons equivalent to 1 goon and 1 rokebkocker though? I think you might be right, but 3 goons is still stronger so I hope the town has a little extra to make up for it.

Well I've moved my vote too. I realised in doing my little talking to myself summing up thing that I suspect Bookwyrm a lot more.

Open role-fishing now? Don't you have any shame? ;-)
And do you have a reply for me?

Pish. I'm openly alignment fishing. I'll be happy to answer your question, but I need an answer from you first.

I'm guessing there is no Serial Killer in play (not enough death), which means that if you're neutral then you probably aren't directly anti-town.

No, that's way too fast.

Unvote

LOL ok. I am for summary justice.

Oof, I forgot Leoric and thought I was fourth. Let's hear from Bookwyrm first.

Unvote

OK, I can vote now.

Vote Bookwyrm

You really expect an answer to such a question? I will claim when I think it is time to claim. Anything else would just make scum's life easier. Do you want that?

I definitely think that there is something scummy about you.

@all: if he hadn't collected so many votes already, I would be willing to vote Bookwyrm. NL vote, voting without reason. Role fishing. Not answering.

Other players I find suspicious are flubb for his reaction to being suspected. Town flubb is usually quite relaxed about being suspected, so his reaction is off.
Then cadaver. I like most of what he wrote, but it looks as if he was tunneling on Dogmaus on relatively flimsy reasons. Of course, Townies tunnel as well, but it's something to keep an eye on.
Lastly Leoric. It's just a feeling so far, but he seems to have a tendency to go after easy targets. But that might also be due to being new to the game.

Catte I don't know. Here I have a question: @catte: why did you accuse me of role fishing? I'm not aware that I did any. You can't role fish on someone who already claimed.

In the town camp I have mostly the same as others.

ZFR has to be town, unless he's godfather. I choose to believe he's town. Which fits his play so far.
Dogmaus is quite towny too and the 'derpclear' (sorry for the expression) seemed genuine.
Joe, well, he has the previous role list going for him. Or more precisely: a scum Joe, who was aware of that list, would probably not have chosen a role from that list for which he would have expected a town counterpart to exist, who would counterclaim. So I have Joe as leaning Town too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8-8WsYj9FU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__Vd1i10FqU

yeah. Hrmph. Still don't know what I did to get the attention of town but oh wells. Tell me after game please when I know your alignment and can trust you.

I know information you don't know and I'm not telling. Booyah!

GOOD LUCK, TOWN, AND BATHE THE SCUM!!!!

I googled deep clear, and I have to say I didn't dumbtell, I was rather role/alignment fished as Town. I never expected this game to have such a wide lingo and complexity when I joined.

22 "BATHE THE SCUM" Votecount

Bookwyrm (2) - Dogmaus, ZFR
JoeSapphire (1) - Bookwyrm

Not voting: catte, flubbucket, Lifthrasil, Cadaver, Leoric, JoeSapphire, dedoporno
It takes 6 votes to reach majority. Bookwyrm is closest to lynch (L-3).

4 days and 22 hours left.
Also...two things:

1. Bolded votes in the middle of sentences don't count, they have to be on a new line. Unbolded votes also don't count.
2. no editing


Ah great, I can't edit the OP to provide live updates. THANK YOU GOG