that's my recap for myself, of what I think it's probable. You don't have to agree with me. :)
As for the 2 or 3, I asked if "Goon" could mean two of them as there was another post saying that there are 3 scum in total. I don't know how things usually are or have been previously. Thanks for your clarification.

Yo Lift, are you a Survivor?

That's why I asked what that was - if it was your interpretation of the current events or somehow it's been confirmed that this is in fact what's going on.

A Goon is a Goon as in single powerless mafia - the equivalent of Town Vanilla. The post says "6xVanilla" and it doesn't say "2xGoon". Anyway, I got my answer, thanks.

Wait, what??!!

...

You're totally right.

I was so totally under the impression that original setup had 3vs8. I completely missed it.

My whole Neutral assumption was because I thought that the best way of switching from 3vs8 to a 12 player game was to simply add a Neutral Survivor.

This of course changes everything.

I take it back, there is no Survivor.

Pooka changed it from 11 to 12 by adding a Mafioso. Did he add a PR to Town to compensate? Did he remove Blocker (or made limited shots)? Guess we'll find out. But that should be an indication to you that there is no Godfather, if there was still such a doubt (and I know how saying it myself sounds LAMIST).

Thank you dedo for drawing my attention to this. I'm a dummy.

As a reward, you get an unvote.

...

Well, this doesn't change my PoE much, but now Lift is in the circle of suspects too.

Vote Lift?

nah

Vote Bookwyrm

This has the added bonus that if he is Mafia and gets lynched he can no longer say he's never lynched as Mafia.

Alarm! Alarm!

Nah, you're the best there is. One can't go wrong by sticking with you!

Oh my!


Damn, why is it every time I feel like voting someone there is a sudden surge of votes against that person?!

I love this. But who's stealing what uniform? XD

I admit, I was ready to start the day voting for Joe too so I don't find this post of Book's too suspicious. The much weirder one is that he came back after Joe's "revelation" and had 0 thoughts on it and left his vote there.

But here's the thing, it's to be assumed that the game has been rebalanced for the extra player. If Pooka increased the number of mafia he probably beefed up the town a little, since the game was balanced for 9v2 instead of 9v3. What I'm saying is, stop this rolefishing!
On flub: Hmm.
___


Don't really follow Cadaver's logic so far re: Dogmaus as of post #787. A 180 when presented with 'new' evidence shouldn't be considered suspicious. Not to mention that Cadaver says that voting for Joe today would be considered suspicious, so as far as I can tell Dogmaus would be damned if she did, damned if she didn't.

Hmm, I do vaguely remember Cadaver having similar arguments in past games but I can't remember which or the alignments.

This is the most aNgErY I've ever seen Flub. He has a point though, Lift normally puts in a bit more effort.

I'm picturing you with a brick on your desk next to your keyboard. Whenever you start to smile because Joe said something funny you pick up the brick, shout "Not today!" and smash the fingers on your other hand.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
It's not like it was unprompted. I was answering a question you posed in a conversational manner.
If you'd pointed out the thing without asking if anyone else remembered and then I'd gone "Wow, I for one had no idea about that!" then I'd say it might mean something. :P

:(

____________


I don't know what to make of Cadaver vs Dogmaus. I don't really follow Cadaver's argument but Cadaver's style seems similar to what I remember from previous games so I don't think it's AI. I think it might be town on town, or at least there's nothing specific there that makes me think one (or both???) is mafia.

On Lift vs flub, I sort of see Lift's point in that there was no real reason for Flub to hammer right then when the day had been extended but I'm not sure what would actually have been gained by an additional 24 hours. I've played in plenty of games where an extension was requested only for the extra 24 hours to make no difference whatsoever. I do see what flub is saying about Lift being... lazy? In my mind, Lift is normally one of the more 'ferocious' players.

I thought this was going to be brutal sarcasm. I didn't really question why you thought Lift was a neutral, but the idea fit with my read of him being off. So maybe he's just scum?

Vote Lift

____________


Is Dogmaus's vote for Bookworm influenced by ZFR's or a slow crosspost? Whatever the reasons, the facts are that Bookwyrm has just gained two votes suddenly and become "a real wagon".

in a way yes, my vote on Cadaver was not meant to be permanent at all costs. And I can suspect one or the other.

Happy eatings!

bump in case catte needs it?

Or weakened Mafia by removing the Roleblocker. Might explain why Micro was silenced permanently and not just blocked.

Yes, I was alarmed at how quickly a wagon got votes in succession this game again. But this time all voting on it are my Town: Joe, Leoric, myself and dogmaus

Not really. I'm just wondering about your motive.