You realise Eng has already claimed right? Not only that but their role (if not alignment) is pretty much confirmed. So obviously you can't mean Eng. Which other breadcrumbs could you mean?

Well in that case you were answering a different question from that asked, because what I asked in 1181 was "why didn't you have another crack at investigating flub?"

So taken in that context your answer certainly comes across as you thinking it was a waste of time, and this is backed up by the fact that you didn't investigate flub on N2.

So again, why the change of heart?

(No votes in this post)
+++++++++++++++++++++++++

Maybe they have two roles? Is that a thing?

----

To all: Is that a thing?

----

If not then I dunno....maybe they are the medic and maybe there is another player as the gender bender?
(Who is not countering for some reason...I know, my ideas are sometimes dumb)

I am just jumping at shadows hoping i'll find something.....also we have bagged two scums, so I am eager to see if we can win this one.

+++++++++++++++++++++

Sidenote: I find it interesting, if the idea of mine is so far fetched, that ZFR seemed to not want to answer while you did.

I received permission. I win when the town is safe from any kind of danger. I guess that makes me practically town. Of course, I still can't prove that in any way.

Since I am a brahmin, I should have the "brahmin kick" day action :)

Replied to Zfr and Engerek:
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Aside: With how I am usually suspected in these games, I find it interesting(just interesting, not suspicious) you didn't investigate me early on.

++++

Is that barhmin kick some game reference/joke, or something serious? :)
(I assume it's the former/first thing I said)

Ok. I guess it's just interesting that you circled back to flub. If flub was as good as any last night, why not the night before? I find it strange that you were on my back about investigating korotan but have no really good explanation for your own actions.
Not only that, but you effectively just ranked flub and koro of equal importance in your own decision making despite finding fault with my choice of korotan over flub. Town or scum, you are being pretty inconsistent here.



Hold on! Your PM should explicitly state that you're town so I'm not sure where the "practically town" thing is coming from. You make it sound like your win condition is the only thing that indicates to you that you're town. Is it because your PM doesn't actually state you're town?

There is Cop investigation and FBI investigation. The former you investigate people you find most scummy and there is almost always someone whom you think to be more scummy than other. The latter investigates, Lynchers and Lynchees and here it's more difficult to find someone who stands out.

It is a joke. Brahmins are like cows. Cows kick. :)

It does clearly state that I am town. I tried to paraphrase it as they are my own words and not something I've read in my inbox. Maybe too much.

Right, but that doesn't mean you just pull names out of a hat. There has to have been something that made you think Flub was worth a second look on N3 that either didn't exist on N2 or was outranked by whatever made you investigate Joe.

Gut feeling? Really nothing much.

Cool beans (i.e. sounds cool)

BTW a nitpick....brahmin ARE mutated cows afaik....so they ARE cows. :)

Well I guess we just wait for the rest to come online. Korotan will be able to confirm I was trying to investigate him and hopefully the medic will see the sense in claiming.

What do you mean exactly by target??

This is a paraphrase as I know quoting PMs directly gets a little dicey rule wise:

[i]I am hiding behind flubb tonight. if flub is killed and flips town I will state that I hid behind korotan.
If you haven't chosen a watch target yet, it would be great if you could follow me. Maybe we could have a repeat of dedo[/i]

again words changed for paraphrase but the point stands: I hid behind flub, if flub died and flipped town I would claim to hid behind koro.

My reason behind this:

I was iffy on joes tracker claim. as long as he knew how the courier role worked, he could have made up seeing both you and trent visiting ZFR. I was going on a hunch that flub and joe were remaining scum. If I drop the tip to joe:

1. Flub is town and joe NKs me or flub: then we have a third night of my hide target getting killed. I would probably be lynched, but once I flip town then maybe everyone would believe that scum had some obsession with following me around. Also I would have stated that I hid behind korotan, and maybe the scum would slip and call me out with more authority than they should have any right to.

2. Anyone else gets NK: then my plan kind of fizzles out and we basically move on to looking into those who connect to whoever received the NK.

3. Korotan gets NK: Had this happened, I would be gunning for a Joe lynch right out the gate D4. I picked korotan as a bluff hide target because them being NK out of the blue would be strange as they have had so little involvement in the game, and if joe was scum he may have taken out koro and lied about the contents of my message. This scenario would have also backed up my belief of flub being scum as well, as otherwise Joe would have just let flub die as another victim of my "murderous" hiding.

Now with joe dead and town, I realize my plan kind of folds. I probably should have guessed that joes time in the game was limited after handing us a scum lynch, but the way that whole event played out just seemed too convenient. The way dedo just gave up smelled too much of a mutually agreed scum bus.

Look at point number 3 from post 1278
That makes him cleared in my view from scum team since dedo flipped sniper