No.

Then why do you say this?

vvv
^^^


Do you think we're definitely NOT both town? What do you think?

Vote Count

(When you see a vote count please quickly make sure your vote is against the correct player. Let me know if it's not)

GameRager 2 - Bookwyrm, dedoporno
scene 2 - Micro, GameRager
flub 2 - trent, JoeSapphire
JoeSapphire 2 - scene, gogtrial

Everyone else - 0
Not voting: Pooka, flub

10 players left. It takes 6 to lynch.

Yep, I think Joe is our man. I also think there's no other scum.
Everyone else has had either at least a single significant contribution that strongly reads as town to me, or has or hasn't had interaction with SPF which doesn't make sense if they were mafia together.

I'll try to do the legwork later tonight to gather my thinking into something comprehensible with quotes, if at all possible. Also to actually convince myself, as right now it's still very diffuse in my head.

Well. My "Gamerager-you're-definitely-getting-lunched-you-may-as-well-come-clean-now" bluff doesn't have quite as much weight behind it...


Looked at the beginning of day one. SirP's first vote of the game is Flubbucket, and flub and he have some banter.

Would they have the nerve to do that? Absolutely.

Would they actually do it? I'd like to believe so but I'm struggling.

Arse.


unvote flubbucket


A bold statement

for such uncertain logic... How much can be read into the people that didn't interact with SirP?


Ugh my brain...

I believe this qualifies as non-sequitur



I think:

Vote: JoeSapphire.

Could you reiterate for each of these why not?

The paragraph above described my whole point (although we seem to be looking at it from different sides). The Town Roleblocker role has the smallest chance of being drawn in the first place. All roles have the possibility of getting counter-claimed as more of the same role is less likely to happen. This relies on 2 of the full role as they alternate between full and 1-shot.

If scum is going to claim a full power role the risk of getting counter-claimed by the same full role is the smallest for the blocker.

I'm pretty sure I understand the mechanics correctly.

This is a thing alright. GameRager is no longer THE wagon, and now there are four others. ..well, I'll do what I said I would earlier and

VOTE GAMERAGER

I"m not really convinced about the flub or Joe wagons, to be honest...

There isn't more to add than what I have said so far and I really don't feel like repeating myself.

The short answer is that these people are feeling the least scummy of the bunch and look like they are trying to figure the game out even though not everyone shares the same opinions (or mine in some cases) but that is only natural considering we are not the same person.

OK, I'm scared now.


This came 3 minutes after Pooka's.

unvote GameRager

Suddenly GameRager is back at L-2 again...I swear, I can't wrap my head around what's going on at times...

Can you explain why did you go from being on Gameragers wago to Joe to Gamerager again in the space of 42 minutes?

I could....

The "sentiment" surrounding GameRanger was palpable. For a minute I decided to allow it to run it's course. I've since come to my senses and will stay with my original conclusion.

GameRanger is scum.