Posted January 10, 2012
Cleidophoros: Pray tell what I should have said?
Mafia 2? Best mafia game ever!
Skyrim? Best cat people game ever!
Metro? Best shooting in the dark ever
CaptainGyro: Yup something extreme like that is obviously the ONLY other kind of answer to the question without seeming picky.. There is no in-between at all. Mafia 2? Best mafia game ever!
Skyrim? Best cat people game ever!
Metro? Best shooting in the dark ever
I don't feel like typing out an example of something that would have seemed less picky, because to be honest I don't care that much about the issue. I just found it amusing that you can't see how your post might make you look picky, even slightly so. It's not that hard to see. You didn't sound like you had any enjoyment out any of those games at all, even though lots of other people have. Hence the picky comment
And since liking and not liking a game is fairly subjective, but also not independent from said games' technical aspects and gameplay mechanics, which should be quite universal, I, of course, expect others having different experiences with said games however other people's experiences don't interest me a bit when I am asked to talk about mine.
I listed shortcomings of said games, even naming one as the candidate for the best game of a genre; I don't think I was being picky or unfair.