So, seems I've raised a few hackles.
Well, I got the reaction I was looking for. Interesting.
drealmer7: (...)
what a silly question anyway, like a spy would answer "oh yes, I am! you got me!"
It was rhetorical.
Brasas: I like this team proposal. I don't trust any of them though :D
This feels unexpectedly right. Not sure why, though...
cristigale: I'm also not fond of agent requesting feedback prior to his team proposal.
@ All - I most certainly had a team in mind when I posted that. It was mostly to see what reactions I would get. WIFOM that how you like.
Brasas: How decisive is he usually?
In Mafia, not very. In Resistance, much more so.
But I've been working on begin more concise and deliberate. How'm I doing? :-D
Dessimu: I have voted and my vote is nay now because I do not trust agentcarr16.
(...)
I'm wounded. :'-(
Dessimu: (...)
- he was happy to join the first mission, even proposed himself - it made me ask myself "why? is he a loyal resistance fighter, happy to help or a spy, willing to pass the first mission to get credit?"
(...)
Mostly it was because I don't feel like playing serious.
Dessimu: (...)
- his, as captain's first question about what team to choose, was too abstract, readable both ways - spy, talking to fellow spies or a resistance fighter, mulling over valid helpful ideas.
(...)
To reiterate, I was fishing. And I got a few bites. We'll see how they turn out.
Dessimu: (...)
- proposed team without clear explanation as to why that team.
(...)
I'll give reasons if you like.
Though I notice that lots of you have already cast votes without asking for my reasoning. Strikes me as kind of odd, that does.
cristigale: I get the same feeling.
JMich: ...
There I go, thinking I've understood how to play the game. Damn it.
I'll try to give some more reasoning as to why I do things, if you guys'd like.
cristigale: So from that, I could see a loyal agent make that request if he is new to this game (like most of us). If he has prior experience, I'm more suspicious.
I've got prior experience. Lots. Just FYI.
Brasas: Can be confirmation bias, but I do recall Agent being somewhat Hamlet like...
...meaning?
I'm going to go ahead and vote on my mission now...