And apparently I managed to erase the part of my post that was a response to this:

Humour me and please point what exactly it was that HijacK did or said that made it obvious he was not only a Power role, but specifically the Herbalist?
And how if it was so obvious 7 of us missed it completely (I'm not ruling out that some on the wagon were scum and therefore may have guessed he was a PR, but even you have to admit that cristi and Bookwyrm aren't scum)?

And if you were so sure and convinced he was the Herbalist why didn't you say as much to try and prevent his lynch instead of whining on about how he was sooooo town, for doing jack all?

OK, I don't want anymore adalia.

I'm warming up to JMich.



Boing boing boing.

Tried to do quick calculations, proved to be too complicated, will have to do a proper calculations later. Gut feeling is that town has slightly less than 50% chance to win the game, since town can afford maybe one mislynch, yet scum need only get lucky once. So it's a case similar to my game, where killing one character would end the game, no matter what had happened so far.

Can we be at one of those moments where I say, "hey everybody lets totally all make a vote and talk and stuff but vote first out k lololol?" and everybody ignores me and just rambles on aimlessly anyway?

Let's be at that point.

I'll start:

Vote JMich

Voting is something we don't do enough of for sure.

Unvote drealmer
Vote JMich

I would still vote for JMich, though babark is my preferred candidate. Let's see how this goes.


Also, @Bookwyrm, your avatar broke the forum... :P

Just to be sure - the "this" in my question refers to the mechanic of Spectres messing with mod-posts you suggested; if this is your answer to my actual question, I'd like to see those proper calculations.
Otherwise, I'd like an answer to my actual question with whatever you got to back it up besides "It would make for an unbalanced and potentially bastard game. What was agent's description of his game again?".



Care to give reasons? Besides "lynch someone already" and "KILL KILL KILL KILL", or anything else along those lines.

Well, I have rumor and hearsay. Those are kinds of evidence.

...


adalia did a thing that I'm not gonna say that if he's scum, I'd be surprised. If he's scum, good fer him, but I was waitin' fer something and another something and basically got it. So I'm off him, probably for good, even though I don't think he handled himself so great earlier. Yes, that probably means he's Mafia Godfather Nazi Cannibal Corspegrinder Bulletproof Berzerker all along, yeah, I get it. But I'm off him. Burn me later if I'm wrong.

JMich has been very opportunistic. Don't like it.

I messed up my quote.

Was supposed to be:

"Well, Your Honor. We have plenty of hearsay and conjecture. Those are kinds of evidence."

Elaborate on this?

Well, that resulted in more discussion than I thought. Yes, the mod's post was what I referred to. As the coroner, I had the ability to have the mod share my results, but it was limited in use.

Adalia was the last surviving scum, but maybe he isn't.
You seem to mention elsewhere that maybe Adalia is scum, even if not the last surviving scum.

And here, there is only one scum.

How do you reconcile the idea of one scum? There is no need for a scum chat N0 if there is only one scum. There is no way for a scum spectre to exist, because the game ends upon the single scum's death.

JMich, you make my head hurt.

Huh. Maybe that's why it's been close to 4 weeks, and my avatar still hasn't updated. XD

He flipped votes around a bunch, and more than that, seems to be casting shade around where it seems likely to stick.

I made a big WRRRROOOAOARRRRR adalia push and I don't like the way he rolled around in it.

I also demanded a peanut-butter sandwich and he handed me a pickle.

Ah, thank you, it seems we still have trouble communicating.
No, the ~50% for town to win (40-60 may be closer) is without assuming the spectres can post mod messages.

Wait, what? You had the ability as the coroner, yet you used it while a spectre? I thought spectres lost their original powers.

Where do I mention one scum in those calculations? If the exorcist dies, scum win. If one scum dies, game continues. The one character refers to the last PR.
Verdict still out on whether adalia is scum or not, but he most likely isn't last scum (most likely refers to my question to cristi higher in this post).

Flipped votes around a bunch? Seriously?
I had one vote on HSL. I then moved that vote to adalia. I temporarily removed the vote to allow cristi to ask some questions. I then put the vote back. Once mod posted coroner's results, I removed the vote.
And who have I been casting shade towards?