It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionForum Mafia #63 Supernatural(876 posts)(876 posts)
(876 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
55
56
57
58
59
This is my favourite topic
Posted December 12, 2019
Well, congrats to the winners and thanks trent for the great setup and hosting. I will have to take a break from Mafia (IRL stuff, don't have time to focus on it anymore for a while at least). Good game everyone.
Posted December 12, 2019
avatar
ZFR: Look at my post 298. "(a) GR started behaving suspiciously again, and". Up till that point I didn't particularly want to lynch GR based on his general behaviour, but his previous post is what caused it.
Hm. Personally I think you should have voted for Lift.

Do we know why they killed you yet? Tell us about these breadcrumbs. I never bothered to go and look... sorry...
If I'm mafia in the next game will I be able to resist killing you Night 1?


I just realised how stupid it was for me to give Lift town-points for iso-ing himself (Lift did you really do it?)
Just because I can imagine few things I'd like to do less, doesn't mean it's something only TOWN would do, what's wrong with me??

Lift, why did you town-read me Day 4? Just to raise my hope so you could dash them further? ;p
Posted December 12, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: If I'm mafia in the next game will I be able to resist killing you Night 1?
No, next time I'm mafia with you I'm going to kill whomever I want and won't be persuaded otherwise by you.. Won't look at whether they've been killed early or not previous games. Out of principle. Even if it means having no night kill because we couldn't reach a consensus.
3 N1s in a row. One two three. That's the amount of days you played this game only.
RFG played 3 games and got to be mafia, jailer and serial killer already. This was my first - first - investigative role in... 12? games since I started playing.
Posted December 12, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: I just realised how stupid it was for me to give Lift town-points for iso-ing himself (Lift did you really do it?)
Just because I can imagine few things I'd like to do less, doesn't mean it's something only TOWN would do, what's wrong with me??

Lift, why did you town-read me Day 4? Just to raise my hope so you could dash them further? ;p
Yes. I did iso myself to see what you might see, so that I could better defend against it. And also to avoid contradicting myself too much.

And I town-read you mainly because I would have done so as town. I usually try to "forget" that I'm scum from time to time and to play as actual town. :-)
But also I reckoned that town- reading you might defuse you a bit and create some confusion. I guess I was right on both points.
Posted December 12, 2019
avatar
ZFR: No, next time I'm mafia with you I'm going to kill whomever I want and won't be persuaded otherwise by you..
That's entirely fair.

I can't wait ;)

avatar
Lifthrasil: But also I reckoned that town- reading you might defuse you a bit and create some confusion. I guess I was right on both points.
I'm a bit dissappointed by how much ROMBUS comes into my game. If you're worried about me suspecting you just give me a little attention and I'll come over all diffused and confused.
Still can't really understand why someone would be worried about me suspecting them. It seems to be a positive thing for scum...

Where's RedFire at? Did he observe? Did he have fun?
Posted December 12, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: Where's RedFire at? Did he observe? Did he have fun?
Sick for some time. Thanks for a great game Trent
Posted December 12, 2019
Oh yeah, if there's any questions about my play, you can ask em now, with the added comfort that this is post game and you all know I am Town now.
Posted December 12, 2019
avatar
RedFireGaming: Sick for some time. Thanks for a great game Trent
Oh no! Are you still ill? Get well soon!

Blotunga too, hope you're all better, or nearly recovered if not
Posted December 13, 2019
I told y'all that RW was scum.
Posted December 13, 2019
avatar
agentcarr16: I told y'all that RW was scum.
I believed you.
Posted December 13, 2019
Well I see the game is now over....and sadly I was wrong on both my picks(joe and dedo), and the ones I mostly cleared were the "truscum".....I guess it's good I died early then? o.0

avatar
Lifthrasil: All in all: good job! It was an exciting game!
It was, and I tip my cap to you for tricking me, good sir. *tip*

Now the observer thread.....eh, not so much(ghost town USA).
==================================

avatar
JoeSapphire: That does NOT mean we should make a habit of lynching GameRager early every game! If we're going to do that we may as well just ban him from mafia.
New rule: L.A.G.(Lynch All Gameragers)....it's the only way to be sure, is it not? o.0 ;D

avatar
JoeSapphire: What it means is we should accept the fact that "saying a lot of nonsense" is just not one of GameRager's scumtells.
Nonsense? Nonsense?!? Bah & ptooety, I say!

(Also sorry for suspecting you....it seems my getting it right streak from the one game didn't hold up long)


=============================

avatar
trentonlf: It’s often the case that people focus too much on setup or roles and lose sight of the actual gameplay.
Serious idea: Why doesn't someone make a game with all vanilla scum and town and list scum/town numbers at the start? That and other things might make people focus more on posts and less on setup, possibly.

============================

avatar
ZFR: I wasn't for particularly for lynching GR throughout the day (though I was willing to if no better candidates came forward). Because yes I agree his behaviour was NAI. Until post 294. The encouraging someone to lie was something new he introduced and meant that he was going to be a problem D2 (or he could be scum).

Look at my post 298. "(a) GR started behaving suspiciously again, and". Up till that point I didn't particularly want to lynch GR based on his general behaviour, but his previous post is what caused it.
Why though? I get it...lynch all liars....but there should be exceptions to that, such as a town hiding a PR till the time is right.
Post edited December 13, 2019 by GameRager
Posted December 13, 2019
avatar
JoeSapphire: Hm. Personally I think you should have voted for Lift.
I believe lift was the wagon before mine(would have to look back)...if so then if we'd stayed on that we might've won. :|
Posted December 13, 2019
avatar
RedFireGaming: Sick for some time. Thanks for a great game Trent
avatar
JoeSapphire: Oh no! Are you still ill? Get well soon!

Blotunga too, hope you're all better, or nearly recovered if not
I've recovered but with a 2 year old and a 2 week old, life is a lot more complicated.
avatar
JoeSapphire: Hm. Personally I think you should have voted for Lift.
avatar
GameRager: I believe lift was the wagon before mine(would have to look back)...if so then if we'd stayed on that we might've won. :|
Yes, when the Joe/Lift shenigans started we should've lynched him :D
Post edited December 13, 2019 by blotunga
Posted December 13, 2019
avatar
GameRager: Why though? I get it...lynch all liars....but there should be exceptions to that, such as a town hiding a PR till the time is right.
A town may use his own judgment to "lie" , rarely, when the situation really warrants it. Outright telling someone else to lie is a no-no. It would have caused you problems on D2.
Posted December 13, 2019
avatar
ZFR: A town may use his own judgment to "lie" , rarely, when the situation really warrants it. Outright telling someone else to lie is a no-no. It would have caused you problems on D2.
On the second line: I disagree....I think telling someone to lie for the right reasons(pro-town) is a more pro-town than pro-scum tell.

On the third line: Eh, my posting style does that all by itself.
Post edited December 13, 2019 by GameRager
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
55
56
57
58
59
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionForum Mafia #63 Supernatural(876 posts)(876 posts)
(876 posts)