Lifthrasil: [...] For example flubbs quick acceptance of HijacK's claim doesn't sit right with me.[...]
Yet when he unvoted HijacK, you had nothing to say. Like when trentonlf first brought up and voted drealmer7 for his "slip", the only thing you had to say was to advice him to bold his vote.
Lifthrasil: [...] Sage feeling off is also related to her questioning HijacK. Somehow her posts read quite incoherent and while I know that that is the way she writes is sometimes difficult to follow, this time it feels like she pieces her articles together from what other people already said. [...]
But when she made that multi-post case, your only comment was that she (re-)raised some good points; you seemed more than happy that she kept the focus/pressure on HijacK, and said nothing about the way she went about to do so.
Also, since Sage103082 feels off only Today in relation to her questioning HijacK, does her "you're trying to make trentonlf unvote drealmer7" push she made on me when I was questioning trentonlf, and the little exchange we had on it read fine to you?
Lifthrasil: [...] It doesn't feel like bussing though. So I don't think she's actual scum and I would place her as neutral, but purely by feeling. [...]
Do you think that there are only two different mafia factions then, and Sage103082 is on neither of them?
Lifthrasil: [...] One thing unrelated to HijacK is JMich's suggestion that the veracity of the flips might be exactly the other way round than we thought. Upon re-read I wonder: was that really just to be thorough and think of all options? Or was that an attempt at misdirection? Or just writing anything new just to have written something new. [...]
Do you think that JMich in particular would write something
new just to appear to be adding something new to the discussion?
Lifthrasil: [...] Oh and something just occurred to me. HijacK said he'd flip 'Muscle'. That doesn't exactly sound like someone who kills using a gun. Which he later added. [...]
Weren't you the first to say that the first thing that "Muscle" brings to mind is Strongman? Is a Strongman kill performed without a gun? Did you change your mind about "Muscle"=> Strongman? If so, what method of killing do you think fits "Muscle"?
Lifthrasil: [...] Also on a side note - we don't get role flips anyhow. Just faction ones. So he would either flip "Mafia" or Mafia. Not 'Muscle' or 'Elite Bodyguard' [...]
You are way too late to this party.
trentonlf: A Death Miller Elite Bodyguard is such an outrageous claim that I find the likelihood of it being in the game very low. The fact that most don't seem to be blinking an eye about the claim makes me wonder just what the hell everyone else has as roles because mine is nothing spectacular (and no I don't want to discuss mine or anyone else's roles).
Initially my question was if you think it safe to be so stark about the likelihood of a given role to be in play based on your own PM (assuming you're truthful about it, that is), given that this is a role-madness game hosted by RWarehall, and that we have nothing else to work with than the two claimed Death Millers. But your post #773 reads to me that it's more that you don't believe HijacK to have said role, than it being that unlikely to be in play.
dedoporno: [...] I will follow my own request to Lift and not intervene in other people's conversations but I have a comment on this one that I'd like to share at some point if no one else does so before me. Please, remind me about it when you are satisfied with Trent's responses on the matter.
I'd like to hear that comment now.
cristigale: At the start of today, we received
adalia's role and gogtrial's gun ownership. I think it's possible we may get more information on the deceased as the days progress. I believe the mod hinted at the possibility in the sign-up thread.
[emphasis added]
Do you think that "Divorce Attorney" was adaliabooks' role? If so, what more traditional role/abilities do you think fit a role titled "Divorce Attorney"?