Yes.

Y'see this isn't a baby, it's a brick of weed.

I could handle a second Hunter90210 investigation.

If you are bored, there is always the option to do something. ;)

Slackers. If you are going to push my lynch, at least don't use statements that are verifiably false.

You heard the man! Lets lynch RW.

Hunter was "confirmed" by a cop who might be sane, insane, or naive. How do you know CSPVG was sane?

Also, I'd love to know how the scum chat went in this theory. Let me take a guess:

N0
Wyrm: Hey Cristi, my only scum partner. You know what would be a good idea? Pushing a lynch on CSPVG on D1. And if he claims a power role, I'll just claim an investigation and keep pushing!
Cristi: Wow wyrm, you are so smart. There is absolutely nothing that could possibly go wrong with that plan. Lets do it!
Wyrm: I had a really successful cop claim last time. No one will suspect me if I claim cop again.
Cristi: True, and even when CSPVG flips town, I'm sure no one will be suspicious.
Both: WONDER SCUM POWERS! ACTIVATE!

N1
Wyrm: Yay! I got a town cop lynched!
Crisiti: Yay! We're the bestest scum team ever! You know what you should do? Totally claim to have exactly the same role that CSPVG did, name and everything.
Wyrm: You're right! That won't look suspicious at all! Let's kill JMich, and I'll claim to have investigated him.
Cristi: Way to plan it! We're so going to win this because they'll never think to lynch a cop with multiple wrong investigative reports!
Wyrm: FORM OF, AN INVESTIGATION!
Cristi: SHAPE OF, A HUNTER LYNCH!

I suppose town could always fall back on the old "try to figure out who is scum without relying on investigative powers". I mean, there's been plenty of conversation and accusations. But I could be wrong.

And I quote: "Repeat, this game has at least one aspect that falls firmly under bastard modding."

We've already got a path to try and narrow cop sanity down. If I hadn't pulled CSPVG's file first, we might be even closer already (depending on the results); I'm not sure how Bler would have handled the files if CSPVG and I had both survived.

Based on how my reads are revealed, I believe CSPVG-Danny is the one drawing that conclusion, not CSPVG-Player. I expect that Hunter = Town was CSPVG's role investigation result.

Calling Hunter665673456 100% town is not logical.

Revealing that one's investigative result was "Hunter = Town" is logical.

Whether that read is 100% correct is a different question entirely, and I agree that giving Hunter a pass based solely on CSPVG's result is not logical.

I've already stated that I think lynching you just to test my sanity isn't a good move.

RW is my favorite right now, but I could go for Drealmer too. My impression of his D1 play reminds me of the All Mafia game, and how he said he started flailing and trying to throw confusion everywhere because he wasn't sure what else to do. His blatant lie didn't improve my Town/Scum opinion of him either.

I'm not sure about Trent, Flub, or Krypsn, and I don't trust my impressions of Cristi. You are in the "I don't know" category; would be nice to get some opinions from you on players and game events.

cristi has been quiet for the most part this game, but I have not found her play to be scummy. She seems to be actively hunting for scum, so no she would not be a choice for me today.

The two I am considering today are bookwyrm and RWarehall.

I want to give bookwyrm the benefit of the doubt and believe his claim, but it's a hard one to believe. I am not sure why we would have two players with the exact name and role, makes no sense. Is bookwyrm trying to steal the identity of CSPVG? Is he really a scum cop and using CSPVG's claim to sow confusion and enough doubt that we don't lynch him?

RWarehall is fixated on bookwyrm. He either believes strongly that bookwyrm is scum confusing us or RW is scum trying to get the cop lynched before we can figure out how to use his reads.

Yesterday I said the best information we could get was by lynching CSPVG. My thought was if CSPVG flipped town then bookwyrm had to be scum. Then when the day started and bookwyrm gave his full claim it instilled some doubt in me, his claim made perfect sense to justify what happened.

Of the two I'm leaning toward lynching bookwyrm, but the fact that there's a bastard element to this game gives me pause about it, but we can't let that fact rule our judgement. Focusing on trying to figure out what the bastard element is just creates confusion and has us chasing our tails.

Vote bookwyrm

I'd like to keep Bookwyrm around, even if he is a insane or random or paranoid cop he can be useful to town in day phase by voting.

drealmer seems a bit off to me, I'd be more comfortable voting for him than Bookwyrm.

@trenton What about drealmer, can we lynch him instead of Bookwyrm?

Hard to argue with that, and I said pretty much the same thing yesterday (note: Nod to JMich for also saying basically this). Unfortunately, I am telling the truth this game.

Assume I flip scum: Great! Scum is dead. According to the 2 scum theory, town has won, or almost won if there is an SK.

Assume I flip town: Now what do you do? What did you learn, except that I'm telling the truth?

If you flip town then my crazy theory is probably true. My crazy theory is that we are patients in an insane asylum. I think most everyone has some sort of mental disorder that makes them think they are still what they were in the real world (cop, Doctor, etc), but in here they are actually just a patient and their roles are not effective or are limited. I would guess you either have a spilt personality (CSPVG was he other half) or you are trying to be him. I would also think whoever the surgeon is did the botched job on JMich. But as I said it's a crazy theory, and if it's true I'm not sure how to proceed.

I've wondered if everyone has the "insane" modifier. JMich breadcrumbed doctor on Day 1, and the non-backup insane doctor might have picked up on that and failed the 50% kill listed on the wiki. That would place CSPVG and I both as insane, making Hunter scum. If a town insane doctor killed JMich, then it would also place RW's "mafia accidently hit traitor" theory as truth, and means that Bulletproof didn't matter.

I don't know how Bler would set up insane tracker, watcher, roleblocker, etc. though.

I'm inclined to think that either CSPVG and I are both insane, or he was naive and I'm paranoid. I don't think he and I were a split personality, because I specifically don't have his number on my wristband. Not to mention, he's dead but I'm still able to play.

The problem with lynching me is that when I flip town, you're out a second cop and a town vote (which might be more important).

Only Hunter has expressed any interest in this, one way or another, and his is a vote for sharing. I just noticed something else that seems important, and I've already pinged the mod to make sure there isn't a mod mistake.

-----
Item 2 first, because the poem was fun to write. I asked several questions about my role, and I got a few (though not all) answers.

The tracker can follow me and see where I go.
The watcher can look, but he'll never know.
Unless maybe he thinks ouside of the box,
For I'll go somewhere, slick as a fox.
Weak I could be, but it matters not.
Death must find me, to cause me to stop.


Maybe that will pique someone's interest.

-----

For future reference, here is my list of choices for a N1 investigation. It was apparently in random order when I received it; I sorted it to make sure it was paraphrased.

7 - Hunter
10
11
24
32
42 - JMich
49
54
68
71

My N0 choices
10, 11, 49, and 54

CSPVGs N0 choices, per post 213
7, 25, and 42

Why must there only be two? Are they Sith?

Yep, with a couple notable exceptions.

You should totally vote for that Krypsn guy, he doesn't have enough 'sometimes vowels' in his name. He is likely hiding something.

First, Flub, you are the one who keeps pushing Hunter as a Poisoner...
Does poison sever one's hand? I think not...
Does a surgeon start pulling organs to remove poison? I think not...

Hence, with no poison kills in the game, it seems your argument falls flat. So why are you pushing so hard to kill Hunter?

Finally, I get confirmation someone else heard a gunshot. Maybe we did have a bullet kill of JMIch given some people are actually starting to share information instead of hinting they have more information and we should just follow them...
Does this mean we have an incapable doctor who tried to save him, but a bullet did the actual deed?

I'm starting to like the Krypsyn/Flub scum team more and more...Flub has said very little this game, yet Krypsyn is acting like we are neglecting his vast contributions...and we have the typical Krypsyn non-contributions as well.

As to Bookwyrm, if you don't see why he's a policy lynch, you haven't played enough mafia. Town does NOT lie! I don't care if you have a power role, you cannot just claim Vanilla because as players we make reads. If you are lying to us, we might pick up the deception. How the heck is town supposed to ever figure anything out when both town and scum are trying to outdo each other with their lies. Bookwyrm claimed Vanilla, later claims cop to get a townie lynched, then says about the only thing he can to save his hide and does so with the Yogsloth patented walls of text filled with plenty of useless fluff. And for all the players saying, if he's scum, he's playing a great game...no, you are playing a poor game. Lynch All Liars. It's a policy for a reason so we don't end up with the clusterfuck of a game where town each keeps playing their one-man games. It's a team game, and Bookwyrm lying about his role (if true) to throw off scum is an example of one-man playing against the scum.

I think it helps illustrate the absurdity of my play in the event of a two man mafia team. Doesn't make a lot of sense even with a 3 man team, but it is a little bit better.

Like what?

Vote Krypsyn.