currently non-consequential

What can I say? I'm clearly the smartest one here and I cannot help that it makes me less likable. It is fallible to devalue someone's thoughts because you don't like the person. Everyone must try to separate their ego from their intellect, those who do not, seem scummy to me.

I think you get it, but, to be clearer, I hope:
also by "flavor name stuff" I mean the hooplah that has arisen by talking about flavor name stuff (me causing a ruckus, etc.), not just flavor-name stuff directly (as in, me voting for dedo for arbitrarily/carelessly sharing PM information that they may not have been certain about its meaning when doing so. Not piecing together the flavor from each person and deciding based on that, which I think could be a mistake.)

Ponder these things:

What if not everyone has a dislike in their PM? What should we make of those people or whatever other information they may or may not have in their PMs? Is their information pure "flavor" too to be disregarded? What if my PM says "you saw so and so slip something into so and so's drink during the social last night" ? What if that so-and-so has been called out as being disliked by someone, and now they are hesitant to reveal themselves, and my PM information that I thought was going to be useful, no longer is?

What if dedo had been the only one or is one of a few/several who do have a dislike? Is that sharing not careless and possibly useful for scum and possibly detrimental for town? I find it to have been an anti-town play, and again, is the straw at which I have decided to grasp. Agree with me, or don't, tell me why you disagree, or don't. It shouldn't be that big of a deal, imo, but the fact that it has caused such a stir, makes me think I struck a chord somewhere.

I think it possibly could have born more weight had the dislike came out after the player was identified as the character, especially in further days. Now, I believe it is possibly useless, and it is you who made it useless by your timing/way you went about it. I realize that this is just a possibility, but I have nothing else better to go on currently.

The flavor itself doesn't mean too much on it's own. But I feel the related discussion provided some interesting results.
No, I care that a dislike for someone was shared without prior discussion to revealing the dislike. If you'd have come out and said "soooo, I have a name in my PM of someone I dislike/hate. Do you all think I should share it or keep it to myself? Who thinks it doesn't matter at all, who thinks it is relevant?" things would have gone differently.

Okay, so why did you do it? Do you then think there IS something to that information that we should be keeping in mind? If so, what?

Very sorry for it seeming that way. I really don't intend to be that way, I simply intend to analyze all angles with a critical eye, objectively. My issues aren't usually with people disagreeing with me, it's when I think someone understands me, twists what I say to seem as if they understood it differently (intentional "misunderstanding"), and then use their erroneous understanding as a basis for an argument against my argument/position.

Of course I consider that possibility and figure it to be most likely, which is why dedo bringing it up adds nothing to the real discussion going on, and I find it to be scummy play, and voted them. If there is something to the dislikings that can be figured out, then I find dedo's play careless or serving scum, or a scum-tactic. Either way, I'm comfortable with my vote on dedo.

I feel yogsloth may have been counting on me to be one of the few who might actually have done that. If I hadn't done what I did, where do you think we'd be now? You're welcome, yogsloth, for keeping the game entertaining.

It seems some people think the information in PMs is pure meaningless flavor (trent), it seems some think there is more to it (dedo), I'm currently uncertain either way. I'm curious where everyone else falls.