Heh.

It should have been two, but I'll accept the one as adequate remonstration. ;)

Obvious you say? This from the guy that hates to role claim, and challenged us to lynch him to find out? Interesting.

*waits for flubbucket's wriggle_out_of_this come back*


Hmmm... would you like me to vote, so you can hammer?

You're like the uber-wife.

"I never said I didn't like your mother!"

"Oh yes you did, it was July 23rd, a Monday, back in 2001. You were wearing that plaid shirt with the hole in it that I hated, had just finished a cheeseburger that you said had a little too much ketchup, and that's when you said you thought my mother wore too much makeup."

"....."

This is one of those times where I hit “post” and then think, “Oh geez, that didn't come off quite right."

Sorry HSL! No insult intended. I’m just in awe of your ability to not only remember things from games ago, but to dig it up link to it with such speed and precision.

Now, because I am neurotic and lose my place so easily, have one of these:



****************************************************
Corrected vote count:

Leonard 6: krypsyn, yogsloth, trentonlf, Ixam, adaliabooks, cristigale
adaliabooks 2: drealmer, bler144
yogsloth 1: flubbucket

It takes 8 to lynch and Leonard takes the lead at L-2
not voting: Leonard, dedo , HSL, HijacK, Bookwyrm

Hahaha, thanks for the image, no insult taken.

Well, if it was from back in 2001, I'd probably not remember, but this was pretty recently, and quite the stance, imho.

As for the link - we can all thank adaliabooks who made it easy to dig up links, even his own. ;-)

Looking at that, and amidst everything that has happened, I'm curious if Flub will clarify why his vote is on yogs at this point.

Which is not to say I'm proposing any specific alternative, it's really that simple: Flub, as of this time, what's the case for yogs over "the field"?

From the outside it looks like a cozy place to camp out without actually having to, y'know, do anything other than idly suggest maybe hammering that wagon or something. And apparently for something he would do himself in the same scenario.

Work wifi completely gave up the ghost so that's why no posts, will be back in a bit.

Same as it was earlier.

Should I call you when things change??

Your Mafia skills really are just the absolute pits.

OK, back to adaliabooks, because I noticed something when re-reading.

I'm inclined to believe that he refuses to answer some of the questions I had asked him in my post #750, as he ignored my follow up request in my post #785. He's also refused to answer bler144's question about that "plain ol' mafia" he said in his post #697. And as expected, he's feeling pretty comfortable now that the attention has shifted away from him, more so as it looks like someone else is going to join P1na and JMich.

So, here's what I noticed [emphasis added at various points].

In his reply to me (post ) he first tried to present his block/jail as a scum one: <div class="quot">If it's a genuine block <span class="bold">by town</span> then <span class="bold">why haven't they claimed it</span>? </div> He followed up on it in his reply to dedoporno (post [url=https://www.gog.com/forum/general/forum_mafia_32_booze_blood_and_bullets_the_prohibition/post670]#670): Because if he was blocked by scum, that would have to mean he's town. Notice the use of the term block, as Roleblocker is traditionally a mafia role.

A bit later he jumps into the "why was HijacK blocked rather than killed?" (sub)discussion between Bookwyrm627 and dedoporno, to point at something dedoporno apparently overlooked (post #678): A Jailer, a traditionally town role, may have jailed HijacK to protect him. On a side note, there's some intimation that HijacK's also town.

He goes on to add something else to this argument (post #683): I'm not entirely sure where the part in parenthesis refers to - is it "they're probably town because they wouldn't claim the action", or "they're probably town because scum would claim it"? Either way, he seems to contradict himself about his own block.

And finally, we have post #717: So, he was more likely blocked by scum, because there's no claim of the action.
HijacK was more likely jailed by town to be protected, because there's no claim of the action.
Yet, the flavour of the two actions is almost identical. Of course, after arguing in favour of the Jailer, he now puts the disclaimer of "at least blocked, whatever that says about his alignment" - but then, the latter part also applies to his own alignment.

Can he have it both ways? I think not.

As for my theory, it's actually quite simple.

adaliabooks claimed two things in relation to yogsloth's soft-claim, if he was scum:
- He and his buddies would let JMich flip.
- yogsloth would have been already dead.

I asked him two questions regarding these statements, but got no answer.

adaliabooks said on several occasions that he thinks yogsloth's more likely to be town (posts #375, #430, and #502). In his post #375 he said:

So, adaliabooks went into N1 thinking that yogsloth's quite likely either Coroner or PGO.

Would mafia-adaliabooks and his buddies risk attempting to NK someone they thought could be a PGO? I think not.
But how could they make sure yogsloth wasn't one? NK JMich, clean up his body, then pressure yogsloth to claim Coroner, by demanding instant results. If yogsloth didn't claim, then perhaps someone else would claim the role, and then they'd be able to take the Coroner out, whoever he is, and try to frame yogsloth for the D3 lynch. As dedoporno said, the Coroner, based on how the role works (yes, I insist on this), becomes a threat to mafia N2 onwards.

I think adaliabooks knew he couldn't get yogsloth's lynched D2, if he thought he'd succeed, they'd let JMich flip.

Mind you this is all based on adalibooks being scum and his take on yogsloth which doesn't seem to have changed since D1. Myself I'm still debating yogsloth, as his play could be of either side, I'm keeping an eye on him for now.
adaliabooks on the other hand, rings all sorts of bells he did in previous games he was scum, particularly RW's game, perhaps a little bit more refined (I suppose that comes with experience).

Looking over the posts of adaliabooks and Leonard03, I'm with bler144, and rather take adaliabooks, but Leonard03's not out of the frame.

We still have time to discuss our options, so thoughts?

Or he's a mad genius.

Hard to say which, really.

Here I am. Catching up. brb

I really have to applaud the effort you're going to to try and get me lynched, it's quite touching really.
But you have completely misunderstood my position here.

I would have expected town to claim a block on someone suspected of being scum (i.e. me), this is admittedly based on the trend of roles and actions being claimed pretty quickly in the last few games so I can see there is a flaw and the fact it has not been claimed probably means little in relation to me as a town roleblocker / jailer may just wish to remain anonymous to protect themselves. I accept that.

My point about HijacK is that scum are not going to protect a target who has been specified by the mod to be easier to kill, without claiming to have done so. What's the point in pretending to be town if no one knows?
Therefore, if you assume HijacK was jailed for protection, the fact no one has claimed it leans more towards it being an action by town rather than scum trying to appear town.

But really nice try to make it more than that. Bravo.

Despite what you think I have tried to answer all your questions so I'm not sure which I've missed... I'm inferring from the rest of your post that one of them was my current thoughts on yog.
As of now, currently not so confident of my read of him being town as his latest twists and turns are looking more like his convoluted scum plots.

Seriously Hyper, you're being purposely dense here. If I was scum and me team had a Janitor, why the hell would we think yogs was a PGO? How can scum (having a Janitor, which is pretty clear giving JMich's non flip) not know that yogs (assuming he isn't one of them) is the Coroner?
Me trying to pressure yogs into claiming makes no sense. If scum wanted him dead, they would have killed him. They will have already known from his hints and their own roles what his role is. They wouldn't have needed to push him to claim.
I just assumed (incorrectly as it turned out) that yogs might have received the flip info immediately and expected it might be shared. Or at the very least, that with the extra evidence provided by JMich not flipping, he would finish the claim he started day 1. I don't know about anyone else, but to me that would be the town thing to do. The fact he hasn't is making him slip down my scale of town players.