Posted November 20, 2015
Leonard03: Bookwyrm is the first to propose 2 scum teams in 672. So Bookwyrm, what made you say this? I'm pretty sure you've played in games with multiple role blocks, and never suggested multiple scum teams before. In fact both you and dedo seem to think the blockers are scum. Why? I have heard that roleblockers are generally mafia roles, but that doesn't seems consistent with what we see here on GOG.
By now it seems almost everyone has decided there are two scum teams. Why? There is no evidence for it, whatsoever. Maybe you Bookwyrm are a mafia roleblockers yourself and weren't on piña's team so you figured out there was another team.
Actually, I often do suggest the possibility of two mafia teams at some point in games I play in. In 659, Dedo posited the idea that both roleblocks are highly unlikely to be scum, so I offered a possible scenario where both could be scum. He already covered the likelyhoods for two scum RB if there is one scum team. Note that either RB could be from a roleblocker or from a jailer; I don't know which. I can't speak for Dedo, but I haven't discounted that both blocks are actually town, or even that one/both RB claims are lies. I'd tend to doubt either of those last two cases, but it is possible. By now it seems almost everyone has decided there are two scum teams. Why? There is no evidence for it, whatsoever. Maybe you Bookwyrm are a mafia roleblockers yourself and weren't on piña's team so you figured out there was another team.
Are there two scum teams? I don't know for sure. Ask me again around Day 5, if we're both still alive.
Nothing personal, Leonard. Did you notice how I got a death threat (well, death wish, anyway) from Ixam, in relation to your wagon? I found that interesting. Did you find it interesting?