Martek: I thought Fight Club was a great movie - and I still think it is - and I'm an "old retired guy".
I wasn't a teenager but an adult when I saw Fight Club the first time (from DVD), and yeah I thought it was great. I also watched it several times back then.
Something has changed though. When I saw it like a year ago from the TV, first I was thinking "Great! I really like this movie, I'll watch it again now!", but somehow I became irritated how everything and everyone in the movie was so supercool and quick-witted, always saying just the right things in a sarcastic and nihilistic way and blaa blaa blaa. I presume I liked all that previously, but now I just found it fake and annoying for some reason. Everyone is so coooooooooooooool! Life's a bitch, and then you bitch, bitch!
And Helena Bonham Carter... I recall thinking how super-sexy she always was in this movie, but now when I was watching her in it, all I could think of was that big-headed actress in Alice in Wonderland, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street and Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, where she wasn't that hot anymore IMHO. Even she had been spoiled by her later roles.
It would be interesting to see Fight Club the first time now, would I find it great or not.