timppu: Looks quite good overall. The (potentially negative) things I could come up with (for now I just watched the first trauma team mission):
1. Parts of the gameplay seemed quite scripted, Call of Duty style. Not sure what to think about that. Maybe that just is how most games are nowadays, dunno. I've seen the same development in e.g. single-player RTS games, more and more scripted events during missions.
2. Were they playing it with a gamepad? At least at some points it didn't feel like it was using mouseaim. I hope the game still supports mouseaim, considering it is in first person.
Anyway, I will probably preorder this, just like I did for The Witcher 3, unless I suddenly hear something quite negative like it would require always-online for single-player or somesuch, but I think CDPR already confirmed it will be fully DRM-free with good single-player experience. For that, CDPR and GOG deserve my money in full.
RyaReisender: The only thing that worries me is that it's first person and first person games usually make me motion sick unless they are grid based. But it looks so cool that I might just give it a try anyway.
timppu: Considering it has so much shooting, I prefer it being first person. Ok, maybe Spec Ops: The Line kind of third-person would have been fine too, it is very close to first person anyway.
I assume it was scripted because it was a demo showcase what it will be in the game, which is understandable if you want to show majority of gameplay, because I really doubt we will get so many weapons in just first hour of the game.
Yes they were playing with a controller, every game is showcased with a controller for smoother transition and easier showing of scenery and details. But, it does make it look bad combat wise.
I really loved the scenery, city, music, atmosphere. The small showcase of dialogue really fits the Punk type of speech being a bit edgy, rough and mature. The driving looked better than I expected considering CD Projekt never did driving, I was afraid it will be clunky or close to Roach riding but with cars. The controller made it look smooth, I hope it will be good with keyboard and mouse.
This small demo showed so much compared to almost everything we saw this year on E3 and Gamescom. I can only hope it will improve since this is just work in progress and many stuff will change.