djmiketjg: Crikey, that's bad luck! I've never dabbled in external drives but internal HDDs have seldom let me down over the years - certainly not to the level that I've had to buy a new one every year. What brand(s) have you been buying?
Pardinuz: Well, I do admit that "once every year" is a bit of an exaggeration. It's been more like once every 2 years, which is still disappointing, imo. I've had mostly Western Digital and Toshiba ones.
Yeah, 2 years is still pretty bad - when you consider drives used to have 5 year warranties (maybe that's why they reduced the warranty). WD should be good enough too. I tend to ignore the horror stories about one particular brand being worse than another - think people have a bad experience with a drive and forever taint that manufacturer in their mind.
To be honest, I've almost always bought Seagate Barracudas and never had a drive go bad that wasn't many years worn. Bad sectors, yes (which is annoying if it happens to take data out you need).
Although I wonder - do your drives just go kaput completely or do they just start struggling to read certain data?