I teared up during the carnival scene, but what really broke me was the "Everything's Alright" sequence. I was rocking back and forth, sobbing, and saying "It's not fair!" over and over again.

For me it was when Eva took River out of Johnny's memories.

Finally found time to play it, and for me it was when they talked at the carnival scene, and you finally find out the meaning of everything and where the mementos came from. Lots of tears.

I did cry a little bit a bit before that, when they're at the doctors.

To be honest, I didn't cry. And I'm a guy who's relatively in touch with his emotions. I have trouble following stories with too many rough edges. Stuff has to make sense to me.

I can kinda get on board with the method of memory transfer. I definitely felt the relationship between he and his wife was poignant. But… without giving away any spoilers, I felt that too much of it was arbitrary; it didn't make sense to me.

Exactly. I was about to cry through practically the whole game, but tears never started due to funny moments, which give relief from emotional weight - this is one of the things I appreciated the most!
The ONLY moment I really cried was near the end, let's say right after the action part...I cried of frustration: that game couldn't end like that! The ending didn't fix it all up for me, it was just lame.

Played for the third time...
That "Everything's Alright" sequence STILL teared me up...

i felt bad when johns brother died .

I didn't like the game of the game much, but it was a great story. I didn't cry, but it got me thinking about some things. What is real? Would I rather have my memories altered before my death so when my life flashes before my eyes, I see something else? Would I want to replace all of my mistakes?

The characters in the story are all quite broken. I appreciated that.

I enjoyed experiencing what was a rather twisted up story and then unraveling it bit by bit.

No tears, my heart grew three sizes that day.