KasperHviid: But is walking simulator a genre in its own right? Is there a common thread in the games with that label, or is it merely a derogatory term?
Anyone tried out the genre? If so, what's your judgement?
As is the case with all genre labels, I think there are various interpretations of what a 'walking simulator' is. It seems obvious that the origins of the term were derogatory in nature, but since it is now being used pretty commonly in the gaming world lexicon to describe certain characteristics of games it is starting to lose the outright negative connotation. In my own mind, currently when I see the term 'walking simulator', I take it to mean:
* First-person perspective
* Less emphasis on fighting, killing
* More emphasis on exploration, discovery, adventure, story/narrative
As you can see, this leaves the label open to encompass quite a number of games. For me, I actually prefer the term 'first-person adventure' (FPA), and I feel it captures the same essence of how people are currently using 'walking simulator' but in a more descriptive way and with less obfuscated derision. The great Sierra text adventures and the LucasArts Point & Clicks, if told from a first-person perspective, would all be FPA or 'walking simulators' in my view.
I have not explored this genre very thoroughly as I am pretty new to the modern-day PC gaming scene, but there are many games in my growing collection which I'm looking forward to trying which I think fit this FPA mold. Currently I am playing Elder Scrolls: Skyrim, and I feel this game could be classified as an FPA or 'walking simulator' depending on how one chooses to play the game.