JDelekto: I can tell you exactly how much space the 1454 games I own from the GOG catalog take up.
HereForTheBeer: Since it's been solved, I just have to know the answer to this question: what's holding you back from getting the final 23 titles? XD
And somehow I thought more space would be required but I guess a whole mess of titles are under 100MB, balancing out the 10-30GB monsters
Funny you should ask. :)
Actually, I think there are probably much less than 23; some of them games I just didn't outright purchase because I didn't feel they were worth getting, however, several items in the catalog were repetitious due to them being the +1 or +2 edition of the games offering bonus content like soundtracks and whatnot. So, for maybe five or so of the games, they had two other editions with bonus content I chose not to purchase...
Some of the games that I have are also ones that have been removed from the catalog for some reason or another, a few of them had been removed, but later re-added.
I also tried to stay away from the real "stinkers", mainly those which received a collective review under 1 1/2 stars.