Hello jason95821!
A lower budget "open world" game that does not get mentioned frequently would be "
Westerado Double Barreled".
It does feature choices & consequences (both inside and outside of dialog options), different endings and replayability due to different unlockable characters, excluding quest lines and a new villain each time you restart the game!
The game's main plot and gameplay revolves around doing errands for people in order to collect evidences on the identity of the murder of your family, so that you can find and confront him. (His identity consists of various appearance and outfit features, and it is randomly reassigned to a different person among the game world's population.)
Kind regards,
foxgog