deathknight1728: 2) The other big reason is that 1st person/3rd person view is only good for shooters. I hate to say it but you get much more versatility with top down view like bg/iwd. Even though im not the biggest fan of fallout 1 and 2 (as compared to tactics), i can handle the games due to the view. I dont know how some people can play those games like gothic and arx fatalis. The storylines are great dont get me wrong, but the view is annoying as shit.
3) The controls. I cant get into any 1st person/3rd person action game as the controls are annoying and extremely difficult to master. The only reason i played fallout 3 was because it was on xbox 360. With the top down view, even games like jagged alliance (that have a bit of a learning curve), are more easily accessible. Games like any of the gothic series, get a big 0/10 due to the controls. Even arx was easier to use than the gothic series.
These are very much Your Mileage May Vary issues. I find FPS games usually have more ambiance than plot, and control well for their intended purposes. (Some, of course, are better made than others.)
Portal, for example, is all about the ambiance. It is better that it is First Person so that anything we meet around the corner surprises us just as it would our characters.
Anyway, you get the idea.