I decided to get this game because of how much people gush over it, but I'm a little disappointed. It's quirky setting is quite fun, the graphics are good (but very glitchy on my system) and the story is okay, if a little uninspired and very linear, and the puzzles are fairly good without being too frustrating.
On the downside, the game is short, about 10 hours. It betrays it's console roots with silly collecting parts (luckily you don't have to collect everything to finish it). The fighting is a simple button mash and rather pointless. The mini-games that might have prolonged the game are ruined by horrible camera angles and controls that make them pretty much unplayable.