ussnorway: yes that will do it... have you got more than 1 system?
if yes [see image] copy the entire game folder from the main system i.e, which ever one you used to add the extra profile & paste that into the other systems... that should fix the error
adding a new profile buggers up the game save order because the profile doesn't track while save game belongs to witch profile i.e, all saves will be lumped together and two saves with the same name i.e, start or auto1 will bugger the network sync
I don't have two systems, but I will delete the profile I'm not using. I'm also currently in the middle of a full deinstall/reinstall. We'll see what it looks like in a few hours.
Edit: The full reinstall seems to have fixed it. I didn't have to monkey around with my profiles.