This could have been a tough choice until I remembered:

Mechwarrior 3.

The best Mechwarrior game ever. Almost impossible to run on modern systems. Above all the fond memories I have with this title.

Great choice, I'd love to properly check out MW3 one day (only played the demo way back when). As for my most wished game? Simple: Blade Runner

For me it would be Chronicles Of Mystery: The Scorpio Ritual, one of my favourite adventure games.

I'd still say the original Grim Fandango...

Wolfenstein 3D.

I'm cheating; I'm naming two games.

NOLF 1 AND 2

Silent Hill 2 probably.

Full Throttle. I hope DF doesn't messes up the remaster.

The Neverhood, Maniac Mansion, and Day of the Tentacle, though admittedly I never played any of them.

NOLF 1. Closely followed by NOLF 2 by the way.

Anyone who named something else is sadly completely wrong...

This is hard, but I would actually pick The Sims Complete Collection as my personal choice.

I am excused because I still have my original disc.

I do, too. What's your point...?

Vampire Bloodlines, Sid Meiers Pirates 2004 Remake. I will NEVER buy those on steam, only HERE!