UniversalWolf: Risen 1 is pretty good. It's a lot like Gothic 1 and 2, so if you liked those at all it's worth a try.
IMO the Risen games go downhill after that, but 2 is not too bad.
IMHO isn't like Gothic 1 or Gothic 2. I've completed Risen and to be honest, i rather play G1/G2 despite the terrible controls. Why?
- Lack of content. One city, one Monastery one bandit camp... How many cities, temples and camps are in Gothic 3? And spells, Gothic 2 have more than twice the amount of spells than Risen 1.
- Boring quests. Gothic 2 have few boring quests, but Risen is infested of filler quests.
- Combat - Bows have a insane "drop" and slow projectile i have a 175 lb crossbow and hit a target at 70m in real life is easier than hit a target at 20m in Risen
- No first person
- Learn magic is a insane bureaucracy.
- Non RPG final boss. Doesn't matter your build, stats and etc. The final boss is your against a generic platform boss
I love Gothic, mainly the 2 and 3 but din't enjoy Risen. Maybe if you like play as warrior in melee and don't see some quests as filler you can enjoy.
EDIT : I've seed videos of Risen 3 and will purchase. I don't expect a game like Gothic 2, but Risen 3 is similar to Gothic 3?