Arkadia: I found my .sav files in "C:\Users\<username>\AppData\Local\VirtualStore\Program Files (x86)\ScummVM" (the files wouldn't show up in a regular search), but I have UAC enabled.

Do you only have the one save file, Adorton? If so, it looks like your save files are being stored in the ScummVM directory where you found it. It's an annoying question, but are you 100% positive you finished the game (waited til the credits started rolling) and took the option to save your character file for export? I can't imagine why a save game would be in the directory but not the character file.

Also, I used ScummVM because QfG1 and 2 refuse to run on my system using GoG's preconfigured methods. Messed with the graphics modes and everything else I could think of and nada. ScummVM ran the games perfectly in half a second.

yankonis: You sir are my hero.

jimmi.s.hansen: If QFG2 doesn't recognise your .sav file as a "proper QFG1 save file", open the .sav file using WinRAR or similar, it will contain another file. Extract this to the QFG2 directory and add the .sav extension. Problem solved!

In my case I played QFG1 VGA in ScummVM and tried exporting to AGD interactive's QFG2 remake. I don't know if it is applicable to other combinations.