happygui: My answer is: just as bad as Jubilost compared to a Grenadier mercenary, which means she's good enough.
jubi Has redeeming qualities.
a) his stats are at least somewhat sensible and are not made with the sole purpose of annoying the player with constatnt bitching and moaning about rest or constant amulet swapping.
b)Jubi has the best camping ability in the game. roughly 10% camping efficiency is well worth slightly less optimal alchemist.
Octavia does not have anything going for her. I can't name one thing she does better than a merc. She could be of use if she'd let jaethal to... improve her. Now then she'd be rather cool. That'd swap her to evil and give her the ability to use the staff and it'd let her use her otherwise useless cha for hp...