Dreamteam67: Lurked for about 45 min watching paradog's alpha gameplay stream, apparently about 2.5 hours in. Psilons massed destroyers, then went and clobbered the humans home planet. Later on creamed a space dragon by staying outside the dragon's firing arc. Both battles no contest.
Gotta say, combat in the alpha version looks really dumbed-down as compared to MoO2: bring bigger guns and more ships, dps your opponent to death. The only thing that looked like "tactics" was ship firing arcs and weapon range, and the player didn't even bother.
I agree, WG devs are aware of the criticism so we'll see if they make the necessary changes. Skeleton of good combat is there, but needs much finer controls. Otherwise the game looks great.
Another stream here -> twitch.tv/lulaboo