Posted January 02, 2019
Rough around the edges, buggy, learning curve, blah blah...well of course those are valid criticisms, but eventually you have to place yourself in one of two camps:
Innovation
or
Refinement
In our culture and economy, a Refinement approach (Think Call of Duty 27: Black Ops 9) tends to achieve relatively higher sales and review scores than an Innovative approach (Shenmue/Supreme Commander)*, but that doesn't mean it's actually a better game. Review scores and other's opinions affect us, whether we want to admit it or not.
As someone who plays and enjoys a wide variety of games, I will take the innovation anyday. At the end of the day, if you are looking at buying this game, you know that you are the type of gamer who might enjoy it, then go for it.
It's a fantastic experience, I played it on Xbox One X when it came out and I gave it another shot on this GOG winter sale here and it has come such a long way. It was already great, but it has continued to improve. Certainly more worth the money now than ever.
I applaud this innovative approach to the "western RPG" genre, and look forward to not only the imitators/refiners but the next innovation from the developers. I hope anyone on the fence just goes ahead and grabs the game because I think, despite it's great reviews, it's an underrated game due to the relatively innovative approach of its design.
Thanks, and have Fun (or don't, I certainly did, but it's your call)
*a few achieve both (Zelda), but that ideal is far from the norm and not the focus of the concept here.
Innovation
or
Refinement
In our culture and economy, a Refinement approach (Think Call of Duty 27: Black Ops 9) tends to achieve relatively higher sales and review scores than an Innovative approach (Shenmue/Supreme Commander)*, but that doesn't mean it's actually a better game. Review scores and other's opinions affect us, whether we want to admit it or not.
As someone who plays and enjoys a wide variety of games, I will take the innovation anyday. At the end of the day, if you are looking at buying this game, you know that you are the type of gamer who might enjoy it, then go for it.
It's a fantastic experience, I played it on Xbox One X when it came out and I gave it another shot on this GOG winter sale here and it has come such a long way. It was already great, but it has continued to improve. Certainly more worth the money now than ever.
I applaud this innovative approach to the "western RPG" genre, and look forward to not only the imitators/refiners but the next innovation from the developers. I hope anyone on the fence just goes ahead and grabs the game because I think, despite it's great reviews, it's an underrated game due to the relatively innovative approach of its design.
Thanks, and have Fun (or don't, I certainly did, but it's your call)
*a few achieve both (Zelda), but that ideal is far from the norm and not the focus of the concept here.