kmonster: Manual p.44
Note that in Melee combat, not every swing is intended to hit. A character in Icewind Dale may make a cosmetic swing during the 7-second round aside from the actual attempt to deliver damage. The swing represents the feints and parries that would occur in real combat
kmonster: If the mace +4 you found is the morning star +4: defender consider yourself lucky, it's the best melee weapon for a solo fighter/cleric in the game.
Oh thanks, that explains it then. Didn't expect that from IWD, even with NWN doing the same.
And yeah, that's the morning star. Blessed helm of Lathander, Black wolf talisman, Bathed-in-blood armor, Gauntlets of weapon skill, Mystery of the Dead shield and Boots of speed. Can't imagine there'll be much improvement left.
I had an awesome cloack giving +1 to AC and saves, but can't wear it with the armor. Also 2 empty ring slots and an empty belt slot. So there's still a chance of doing slightly better.