My Windows 8/8.1 experience (this is actually on a laptop which I owned before, but sold to someone who wanted a gaming laptop; but I am currently still in possession of it, trying to troubleshoot the problem which I mention at the end):
Positives:
+ The desktop mode seems to have less fat than Windows 7. I'm using two Windows 7 machines, and both have this odd tendency to sometimes "go through" all the icons on my desktop and task bar, ie. all the icons are first empty (white) and then they appear there one by one, like one per second. What the heck is that? It usually happens when I boot to Windows 7 desktop, sometimes elsewhere too (e.g. when I activate the VPN connection to my workplace on my work laptop).
I haven't seen similar on either Windows XP nor Windows 8, when I go to desktop on either, there is no such waiting period for desktop icons to appear. Maybe it is due to Win7 Aero or something.
+ I think Netflix works better in Windows 8 than in Windows 7 (HD support).
Negatives:
- I still find the Metro start screen thingie somewhat confusing and distracting. I think I still have several "Manual" icons one after another on it which belong to different GOG games, and Windows 8/8.1 is just unable to group them similarly like they are grouped in XP/7 Start menu.
- I dislike the default full-screen Metro versions of Internet Explorer, Skype, PDF reader and such. Those shitty tablet apps should have been left to Windows RT. Fortunately you are able to use proper desktop replacements instead of them.
- The worst one: After some Windows (8.1) update a month or two ago, Windows 8.1 broke down. When I boot to Windows 8.1, I end up in a black screen, and I can only shut it down with the power button.
I googled for it ("Windows 8" "black screen"), and many others have faced the same, some already when they upgraded from Windows 8 to 8.1. It seems the culprit is that Windows Update and graphics chip vendor (NVidia in this case) driver updates collide somehow, e.g. Windows Update also "updating" the graphics driver and overwriting some vital parts, which cause the black screen due to corrupted graphics driver installation.
However, the suggested fix is to boot to Windows 8 in safe mode and re-install the graphics drivers from scratch, but for some reason that doesn't help me, I end up to black screen also in Windows 8.1 safe mode. So I am not confident it is exactly the same thing, even though symptoms seem very similar. There is some recovery mode I can get to in Windows 8.1, but it is not the proper safe mode and I can't do anything there.
Windows 7 still works like a champ on that same PC (Windows 7 and 8.1 are installed side by side). I can still see all the Windows 8.1 files on their own partition. Since all the recovery actions and such seem to fail too (e.g. it claims it can't find any recovery points for Windows 8.1), the laptop is now just running Windows 7.
Maybe I'll wipe the whole PC at some point, but I am unsure if I install just Windows 7 on it, or still take my chance with 8/8.1.
Post edited March 19, 2014 by timppu