ITT we write down the most ridiculous, improper or otherwise interesting games that people requested and voted for in the wishlist. Categorizing them is a plus. I'll start, of course
- games so new it's bordering on trolling
The Witcher Enhanced Edition (no less)
Crysis Warhead
Assassin's Creed
World In Conflict
Dead Space
HoMaM V datadisks
- new games nobody should want
Doom 3
Peter Jackson's King Kong: The Official Game Of The Movie
- MMOs
whole bunch of Guild Wars... and World of Warcraft of course
- typos
Pinkiller: Overdose (got 10 votes)
- console games
Tekken 4
- obvious jokes
Starcraft 3
Wii Sports (that made me laugh)
- misc
XCom (just that)

How many of these threads have we seen? But yours has the best grammar, I'll admit.

Yeah, sorry, I suspected this might be kinda overused topic, but I couldn't resist. Although, I did a quick search, which turned up nothing.

I would play a game called PinKiller. Where can i buy that one?

I liked Doom 3 :(, just pretend its not a Doom sequel and its great fun.

people can wish for any game they want, it's a wish list, the likelihood doesn't matter, you can wish for anything you want, like I can wish for a solid gold fiddle that plays like a dream. it doesn't mean it's going to come true.
Hell, I even wished for a game called Fartcraft, and I really don't think it's a real game.

Do you happen to live in Georgia? I once heard of a deal like that happening around there...

http://www.gog.com/en/wishlist/

PinKiller: Overdose... This was that one they renamed 'Extreme Bowling 5000' for Europe right?

And the word "tomfoolery" was used... This is a good thing.

The game "A Solid Gold Fiddle That Plays Like A Dream" is getting lots of points, anyone played that game? Sounds like a fun one. : )

Now I know what "tomfoolery" means.

Doom 3 may have a good modding scene, but it's nothing compared to any of the UT games.

That's possible, but I've never tried any mods for UT. Which is rather weird considering that I've got all the games, except 2003... I find that the UT games are so well done that I don't need any mods.
EDIT:
Dungeondoom. I doubt any of the UT games has a mod like that.
You did inspire me to go look for mods for UT2004 and UT3 though.
EDIT2:
After a few minutes of searching, I see why you think that the UT games have a better modding scene. Lots of amazing stuff. Still, DooM 3 got some good mods as well that makes it worthwhile.