Posted October 11, 2012
I've been a PC only gamer since the SNES really, so I don't think in terms of generations to be honest. Also my answer would depend on genre...
1997-2001 for RPGs, starting Baldur's Gate and ending with Morrowind/Deus Ex.
2000-2006 for shooters, including my two favorite shooters ever FEAR and Crysis, along with a ton of other standouts. Earlier than that they were mazes, later than that they were linear corridors. This is the sweet spot for me.
1994-1998 for adventure games, covering the LucasArts classics and the few (IMO) Sierra standouts.
I don't really play other genres.
1997-2001 for RPGs, starting Baldur's Gate and ending with Morrowind/Deus Ex.
2000-2006 for shooters, including my two favorite shooters ever FEAR and Crysis, along with a ton of other standouts. Earlier than that they were mazes, later than that they were linear corridors. This is the sweet spot for me.
1994-1998 for adventure games, covering the LucasArts classics and the few (IMO) Sierra standouts.
I don't really play other genres.