Ebon-Hawk: Well you know how it is, you give people a voting button and they will turn it into their very own rating system and will mark everything that disagrees with them down...
Actually, rep has not always been a problem. I believe most folks who have been around for a while will agree. It was used almost exclusively for up repping with maybe 2 or 3 trolls being down repped over the first couple of years.
After the site left beta, the rep system was broken and we had an influx of people . . some of which were very obnoxious and trollish to an extreme. Rep abuse basically started at that point and quickly got out of hand. Finally got to where multiple alt accounts were created which cause even more rep abuse and escalated the whole problem to a new high. As the alts were discovered they were then flaunted and justified which brought even more down repping.
The rep system was fixed but we were left with a few members who are totally focused on rep. They also refuse to accept that the community . . . as a whole . . . is now down repping obnoxious / trollish and profane posts whereas most would not have done so in the past. Paranoid that "they", "them" and . . . my favorite . . . "old timers" . . . are out to get them . . . we have an almost daily rant about rep. IMHO, "old timers" are the least likely to down rep but I have to admit it looks more attractive the longer GOG allows the posting that triggers down reps to continue.
The above does not begin to cover what has happened over the last several months but it is the "skinny" from one "old timers" point of view.
I don't know that the GOG community was ever a "classy" community but one thing is for sure . . . it no longer is. Seems the trolls won eh? Welcome to the new "trashy" GOG community . . . =)