Jernfuglen: According to gamerankings.com these 2 games are at about the same level of quality, and the part I tried of silver was actually quite satisfying, so I don't why it should be fatal. (I know, that all you actually get from gamerankings is a number, but I'd still say that it tells something)
meudoland: mmh, about RPG aspect:
http://www.rpgfan.com/reviews/soulbringer/Soulbringer.html http://www.rpgfan.com/reviews/silver/Silver.html UNDERSTOOD the difference now?.......
I SEE a difference now. The review of soulbringer is quite positive, and silver seems medicore, but it seems you've found a review of the dreamcast version, which is inferior to the pc-version.
If I wanted to, I could find other reviews, that gives a better impression of silver, and a worse of soulbringer, (e.g. gamespot.com) and then we could go on and on, forever and ever.
Anyhow, it was not my intention to make a contest of which game is the best, only to tell that I would like to play silver. If we get both games, I guess we should both be happy.