Weclock: Because there's no point to showing a gratuitous sex scene without that being the case. You can quite clearly and quite easily create a sex scene without having to show "TEH TITTAYS!"
And because I myself have found this too difficult to put in words, I will quote a friend of mine from another forum
"I think that decades and decades of film making under stricter censorship laws have taught directors how to imply sex so that people who are adult enough to understand it will understand it, and those who aren't won't, and we really don't need to show a dude thrusting into a lady on screen. Not because it makes me personally uncomfortable (Although it does,) but rather because I think it makes a lot of people uncomfortable, and the people who derive joy from seeing that are either 1.) Undersexed porn fiends or 2.) Capable of deriving the same understanding of the character from a more subtle scene." -- Jeff.
I'm pretty sure you don't understand the context of the sex scene in Watchmen. If you take a good look at the graphic novel itself, you will see that the sex scene occupies a single page out of the total: 424 pages. This example gives further support for the sex scene in the movie, since the movie is meant to be faithful to the novel itself. You act as if the director of the film consciously inserted this scene to attract more viewers. If this were true, we would have heard a lot more about the sex scene BEFORE the movie was released. Otherwise, the "intent" you suggested is completely invalid.
For those people who are made uncomfortable by such sex scenes, there's something called the rating system, and if I remember correctly, Watchmen is rated R. This is not an accident. Screeners have identified potentially offensive material and this rating shines brilliantly in the face of anyone who watches it. I consider that a fair warning.
In response to your friend's comments, you both seem to categorize images as either causing pleasure or displeasure, while not acknowledging any emotion between those extremes. Showing a sex scene is not purely about the carnal desires of those depicted onscreen, especially in the complex world of Watchmen. It's about putting the audience in the moment, as well as in the minds of the characters. If the characters happen to be engaged in love-making, then so be it. This moment is only a fraction of what Watchmen has to offer. Don't ask people to tone things down just because you're not comfortable with it; real life does not work that way.
And I'll end with a question to you. Did you play Mass Effect? Were you so reviled by the sex scene that you denied the magnificence of the rest of the game? Did that prevent you from finishing (or even buying) the game? I knew about the sex scene before I bought the game, but I was much more excited by the gameplay, plot, and characters than I was by the impending 30 second cinematic