What 5 dollar game do you think is MOST worth my time?
I already have:
DUKE NUKEM 3D: ATOMIC EDITION
ROBINSON'S REQUIEM COLLECTION
ODDWORLD: ABE'S EXODDUS
ODDWORLD: ABE'S ODDYSEE
FALLOUT TACTICS
STONEKEEP
WAXWORKS
FALLOUT 1
FALLOUT 2
So? Help 'Ol JJ out?

What kinda game do you want to play?
I can recommend both the Freespace games without a second thought. Probably some of the best games I've ever played.
If you want some arcadey style FPS, then you can't go wrong with Rise of the Triad or the Blake Stone series.

Duke Nukem: Manhattan Project is awesome (if you can play all the way to the end with no crashes), Earthworm Jim 1+2 are both great platformers too, and Flatout is one of the most enjoyable racing game I've ever played.

I'm looking at your avatar and asking: You don't have Fallouts?! Insta-buy. Best open-world RPGs in history of the genre

Looking at your list I'd put my money on you might be a bit of an RPG fan.
Therefore I would say if you haven't got it already Arx Fatalis would be a good $5.99 buy.

If you like open-world RPGs, go for the Gothic series. Very enjoyable games!
I'd also recommend the Freespace series, if you like space-based shooting action.

Oh yeah, it was list of what he already has, not what wants to choose from... Sorry, my mistake, carry on :D

Stronghold.

I agree, Arx would be a great choice. I think it has stood up to the test of time very well, and its easy to become involved in the story.

Either Flatout or Duke Nukem: Manhattan Project. Oh, and Broken Sword II.

Well, I use to like rts but there all the same, I was thinking Gothic one or two (and I know they are 10 buck games) because I have always been a fan of TES, but not might and magic.

Fallout 1 because there's simply soo much fun to be had.

Yes what kind of game are you looking for?

Yes, I do believe that the fallout series is the greatest technological advancement, ever. Hah...