Zookie: First of all I want to say that I love GOG. For the price of a eating out at a dirt cheap restraunt I can get a new PC game... Awesome. With that said I am trying to choose between Castles and Lords of the Realm. I played Lords of the Realm 2 way back when it was new and remember liking it but I never owned I just played it a few time. Castles is completely new to me but I have heard good things (I am on a Mideaval kick for some reason). I like complex and challenging strategy games that have many paths to success. To get an idea what I like, some of my favorites are Civ II, Imperialism, Creaser III, MOO2 , Rome Total War, and Hearts of Iron II. With that said would you recommend Castles or Lord of the Realm and why? and feel free to plug another great GOG stratagy game while you are at it.
Thanks!
Those are good favorites :)
I've played Castles II and I can tell you that Castles II is a great game. However, I do have to warn you that there is currently a bug in Castles II wherein you probably won't be able to load from a saved game. The details are
here. Unfortunately this issue has not been resolved by GOG.
I've not played it myself, but Master of Magic is essentially Master of Orion (same people) in a fantasy/medieval setting and I've heard good things. The Heroes of Might and Magic and Stronghold series also both have good ratings (and again never played myself).
Castles II also has a lot of personality in addition to the strategy with plots and intrigues as well as great little BBC videos about the history of, building, attacking, and defending castles. Unfortunately it does have that bug. Castles II is also an older game than Lord of the Realm II. However, like you with Lord of the Realm, I have a lot of fond memories of playing Castles II.